1. Interface design

1. Overall feeling

In this item, the rankings of the pros and cons of the three software are QQ Music, KuGou Music, and KuGou Music. I music.

In addition to the obvious advertisements of Kuwo Music, the music icons of each channel are too fancy and dense, which makes people look a little uncomfortable.

Kugou Music’s advertisement is the least obvious, but due to too many elements, the overall feeling is not crisp enough.

QQ Music does a relatively good job in this regard, and the overall feeling is very clear, clean, and well-organized.

2. Search box design

In this item, the rankings of the pros and cons of the three software are KuWo Music, KuGou Music, and QQ Music.

I feel that only two good and bad factors are considered here, namely obviousness and reasonableness of location. Among the three, the search boxes of KuWo Music and QQ Music are more obvious, but the search box of QQ Music loses in location. The search box and search results are divided into two different sides, which is not in line with the user's usage habits.

3. Current music playback menu design

In this item, the rankings of the pros and cons of the three software are QQ Music, Kuwo Music, and Kugou Music.

The overall menu design of QQ Music and Kugou Music seems to have a compact and balanced distribution of elements, and the design of the progress bar is more obvious. However, the menu of Kugou Music is placed at the top of the playlist. . In other words, the song selection is done from below, and you have to look up when you are finished, which is not in line with user habits. Besides, looking up is always more tiring than looking down.

4. MV interface design:

In this item, the rankings of the pros and cons of the three software are: Kugou Music, QQ Music, and Kuwo Music.

Kugou Music’s MV allows users to switch freely between the original singer and the accompaniment singer without reloading or seeing half a second of advertisement.

QQ Music’s MV has a ten-second opening advertisement. The MV plays for less than a minute, and then there is a pop-up advertisement of a few seconds.

When the MV of Kuwo Music is switched between lyrics, original singer, and accompaniment mode, the song will be played again and the loading is slow. At the same time, the advertisement must be watched again every time. MV navigation comes and goes without a trace, which is extremely inflexible and not conducive to operation. In addition, there is no close button in the playback window!

2. Content

1. Category

In this item, the rankings of the pros and cons of the three software are: Cool Dog Music, QQ Music, Kuwo Music.

The classification of Kugou Music is relatively clear and the logic is clear. The classification of qq music makes people feel a bit confused and unclear. Kuwo Music only has major categories, and the following is a mess.

2. Quality

This item refers to the quality of free music. The rankings of the three softwares are: Kugou Music, QQ Music, and Kuwo Music.

3. Relevance

In this item, the rankings of the pros and cons of the three software are: QQ Music, Kuwo Music, and Kugou Music.

On QQ Music and Kuwo Music, when the mouse is moved over a song in the playlist, a content box with related information will pop up, allowing the user to enter the corresponding singer information page or album. Information page.

On the qq music player, when you click the icon of the currently playing music, you will enter the corresponding album.

Kugou Music’s songs do not have any relevance in this regard.

3. Sharing and interaction

In this item, the rankings of the pros and cons of the three software are: Kugou Music, Kuwo Music, QQ Music.

Kugou Music has made a lot of efforts in sharing and interaction, and its community characteristics have become more obvious. Reflected in Kugou Karaoke, Fanxing Performing Arts Platform, original music base, and user music sharing based on "nearby", this is the rhythm of music to the end.

In addition, Kugou Music’s rating system is more rigorous and accurate, and users can choose between 1-5 stars.

Kuwo Music does not have a rating system. The biggest highlight here should be the relatively complete karaoke system, but this is not actually interaction and sharing, because there is no good way for users to The work can be disseminated and shared.

QQ Music lacks a lot in this aspect, and music users are not able to participate in the interaction well. Even the sharing of music can only be shared on its own platform, and there are only two options for rating music (as shown below), which is not rigorous. In fact, QQ Music relies on QQ, China's largest community platform, and using these social elements to make users active should have good results.

4. Speed ??and performance

In terms of song loading speed and search speed, the rankings of the three softwares are: Kugou Music, QQ Music, and Kuwo Music.

However, one thing that needs to be mentioned is that if the user’s current network speed is relatively slow, then using Kugou Music will obviously feel that the Internet is blocked. Therefore, Kugou Music’s bandwidth usage is Rather domineering.