Current location - Music Encyclopedia - Chinese History - A blockbuster that is inconsistent with history.
A blockbuster that is inconsistent with history.
1. Choose a historical film and television drama that is inconsistent with history. 1 All TV dramas about gentlemen are inconsistent, such as Liu He. Neither Ji nor Liu in history dared to confront the gentry head-on.

In history, the harem of Yongzheng was actually simple and clean, and there were not so many fights. In office 13 years, very diligent. Besides, he was too busy in the previous dynasty to take care of the harem. Empresses in the palace all wear makeup.

In the Qing dynasty, concubines went to the emperor's bedroom. Since Yong Zhengdi, eunuchs usually get green cards after meals, emperors get green cards, and turned concubines serve as beds. This princess wants to leave the dragon bed after sleeping in it. Why? There is no record in history. This may be: first, for safety, to avoid the assassination of the emperor after sleeping soundly; Second, for the sake of health, avoid the emperor's bad rest at night; Third, for "work", lingering in the bedroom at night will affect the early morning of the emperor in Yin Shi (4 o'clock in Andrew). The plots in The Queen of the Palace are all false.

I met King Guo Jun, met him many times in Yuanmingyuan and the Forbidden City, and fell in love. Later, when Zhen Xuan became a monk, he decided to elope.

2. List examples of historical dramas inconsistent with history, the famous Ji Xiaolan with iron teeth and copper teeth.

Born into a noble family, his father Ji was a famous textual research scholar and worked as an official in Beijing. Ji Yun was brilliant since he was a child and was known as a "child prodigy".

In the 12th year of Qianlong (1747), Gaozong was awarded the title of Xie Yuan after having passed the rural examination. In the 19th year of Qianlong (1754), he was elected as a scholar and was elected to Jishi Shu, imperial academy. After editing, the library was moved to Zuo Chunfang and Zi Chu.

After the governor of Beijing, he was awarded the magistrate of Duyun Prefecture in Guizhou. Emperor Qianlong was still an illegitimate child because he appreciated his knowledge and added four titles.

Soon, I was promoted to the Imperial Academy as a bachelor. In the thirty-third year of Qianlong (1768), he was involved in the salt policy deficit case because he tipped off Lu Jian, his in-laws, and was sent to Urumqi, Xinjiang. He actively communicated with the local people along the way and said, "If I heard about it," and wrote many works, which were later compiled into a book, namely the famous Reading Notes of Wei Caotang.

Ji Yun's opposition to Neo-Confucianism is deeply reflected in Notes of Yuewei Caotang and Summary of Siku Quanshu. Two years later, due to the need of writing a book by Emperor Qianlong, he was recalled from Xinjiang on the recommendation of Liu Tongxun. In the thirty-eight years since Qianlong (1773), he was the editor-in-chief of Sikuquanshu Library, with a collection of 3,503 kinds and 79,337 volumes. He also revised the Summary of Sikuquanshu and Records of Jehol.

Editor-in-chief, assistant minister of the Ministry of War, assistant minister of the Ministry of Rites Zuo and Shangshu. In folklore, Ji Xiaolan is charming and handsome, and his relationship with Gan Long is the right-hand man of a wise monarch, full of trust, ridicule and humor.

Ji Xiaolan is honest, witty, handsome and free and easy. He is tit for tat with Xiao Shenyang, always waiting for an opportunity to play tricks on his opponent and make a fool of himself. I often succeed in avoiding the revenge of Xiao Shenyang, and the whole vacation is true. In fact, this is not the case in history. These stories are all well-intentioned beautification that people take for granted, and they are all false.

According to relevant data, the true image of Ji Xiaolan is quite different from folklore. The real Ji Xiaolan in history is short-sighted.

"Sleepy-eyed" means ugly; "Myopia" is myopia. This college student not only has these shortcomings but also has the problem of stuttering. Zhu Gui once wrote a poem about Ji Xiaolan, "Hejian Zongboheng is good at stuttering and writing a book.

Immersed in four warehouses, summarizing and recording ten thousand volumes. "But objectively speaking, since Ji Xiaolan can pass the imperial examinations at all levels, his appearance is definitely not' sorry for the audience' but' passable', but there is no doubt that Ji Xiaolan is ugly.

Under the standard of judging a person by his appearance, Zhicheng Deng, a historian of the Qing Dynasty with congenital deficiency, said that the selection of Qianlong was "judging a person by his appearance, and Wenda (Ji Xiaolan) was short-sighted and was from Jiangbei, so he was not liked by the Qing emperor (that is, Qianlong). At that time, if Weng, Zhu, Wang Lanquan and Zou Yigui were all rejected as officials, their fate was quite similar. The pure emperor allowed them to be wise and sensitive and led them to become governors.

If Yu Wenxiang, Liang and Dong Wengong are all jesters. "Qianlong's employment standards for nearby officials not only require these people to be agile and smart, but also to be handsome and handsome.

Small Shenyang, Wang Jie, Yu Minzhong, Gao Dong, Liang Guozhi and Fu Changan are such examples. Therefore, even if Ji Xiaolan is brilliant again, his "shortcomings" such as general appearance, myopia and stuttering are also the important reasons why Gan Long and Ji Xiaolan have been separated for a lifetime and can't get real attention.

It is very difficult for Ji Xiaolan to become a favorite and minister of Qianlong, and it is also difficult to participate in major political decisions. He can only settle down in words and be a dry ci minister. Ji Xiaolan served as an imperial envoy of Zuodu in Duchayuan, and his misjudgment should be punished by the ministerial committee. However, Gan Long said, "The appointed Ji Xiaolan is a useless pedant who just wants to fabricate figures. Moreover, he is not familiar with the names of criminals and other matters, and it is excusable to make mistakes because of myopia. "

A well-educated college student in A Talented Man and a Beautiful Woman turned out to be a "pedant" in his master's mind. How can a person stop saying that he was sad? Ji Xiaolan worked as an examiner after having obtained the provincial examinations twice, six times and three times as a history official. These are all official positions without real power, just vase-like decorations of the Qing court, and the embodiment of his real experience as a ci minister.

Emperor Qianlong asked Ji Xiaolan to compile "Sikuquanshu" in order to give himself more powder and get more gimmicks for his "sandwich martial arts". Let Ji Xiaolan be the editor in chief. This is because Ji Xiaolan really has unparalleled talent in this field. Gan Long thinks that he can only do part of this kind of work, instead of treating him as an independent etiquette.

Ji Xiaolan was fifty years old when he compiled Siku Quanshu. He devoted a lot of energy and painstaking efforts, and with his profound knowledge and amazing willpower, he made great contributions to the preservation and arrangement of China's ancient cultural heritage. Ji Xiaolan managed Sikuquanshu for thirteen years, and personally wrote the General Table of Sikuquanshu and the Concise Catalogue of Sikuquanshu, and his life's brilliance and brilliance reached its peak here.

In the process of compiling Sikuquanshu, Ji Xiaolan and many colleagues suffered embarrassment, hardship and even family destruction brought by writing, and it is difficult for future generations to see the pleasure of "climbing the grid". Liu He, the chief editor, and Lu, the general school, were repeatedly reprimanded by Gan Long and handed over to the Ministry for discussion, and were fined for their mistakes.

Finally, editor-in-chief Lu froze to death on the way to Shengjing School. Lu's principal was dismissed because he could not afford the cost of revision, and died of depression. After his death, his ancestral property was still confiscated. Ji Xiaolan has also been reprimanded and punished many times. After the re-examination of Sikuquanshu was completed in forty-five years of Qianlong (1780), many mistakes were found, and Qianlong "ordered discipline and land to pay compensation equally".

Colleagues and their own personal experiences have brought Ji Xiaolan a deeper feeling and made him truly aware of the sinister environment in which he lives. Ji Xiaolan Tengda started as a pen and ink inkstone, and embarked on a career with words. During the Qianlong period in which he lived, it was also the period when the "literary inquisition" reached its peak, which of course gave Ji Xiaolan nightmares.

Ji Xiaolan left a copy of Notes of Yuewei Caotang to future generations. This note is widely circulated. Mr. Lu Xun said that this book "measures the realm of ghosts and gods, making people feel subtle."

Sun Li thinks this note is "the same as Strange Tales from a Lonely Studio". Ji Xiaolan also wrote such a note, which is really helpless. He witnessed too many people being carried away by words.

When the book was finished, he repeated regretfully, "I spent my whole life killing people."

3. Which historical TV play is inconsistent with history, and what are the inconsistencies? About a few years ago, it was the hit TV series Kangxi Dynasty.

The obvious differences are as follows:

About people: 1. There is no such person as Rong Fei in history, and their daughter Lan Qier is also fictional.

2. Kangxi's daughter didn't marry Ge Dan.

3. There is no Wei Dongting.

About the plot: 1. Most of the people who don't exist in the above history are fictional or body double flowers.

2. The emperor likes Ma Su Lagu and wants to be a princess. In fact, Ma Su is only a little younger than Xiaozhuang and can almost be the grandmother of Emperor Kangxi.

According to the regulations of Qing Dynasty, only the empress dowager and the imperial concubine can call the empress dowager, and other concubines call themselves "handmaiden". Tong Fei is just a princess, and can't be called "Huang E Niang".

Xiao Zhuang died in the 26th year of Kangxi and didn't live as long as in the play.

5. Mingzhu and Suoetu died in the forty-seventh year of Kangxi and the forty-second year of Kangxi respectively, so it is impossible to be alive in the sixty-first year of Kangxi.

4. What contents of the film elizabeththegoldenage are inconsistent with history? Before each scene of the impressive Fozelinge by Queen Mary of Scotland, they showed the castle surrounded by the majestic mountains of Scotland, and the top of the castle was covered with snow.

Fotheringay is actually in Northamptonshire, one of the flattest counties in England. Queen Elizabeth stood on the top of a cliff near her camp, which is said to be in Tilbury, and looked at the burning fleet.

But Tilbury is located at the mouth of the Thames, far away from the incident and the striking jagged rock where Elizabeth stood. In the film, Elizabeth's potential suitors include Tsar Ivan IV and Eric XIV of Sweden of Sweden.

At the time set in the movie (1585), both monarchs have passed away (Ivan at 1584 and Eric at 1577). Even if Ivan was still alive, at that time, the orthodox rulers were unlikely to marry the Protestant queen.

Besides, when the film happened, Austrian charles ii should have been 45 years old, not only a boy, but also married and had 1 1 children. Mary Stuart (Mary, Queen of Scots) was hacked to death with a quick axe.

Historically, the situation was much worse. In fact, it was at least twice-the first hit on the back of Mary's head (which reportedly prompted her to shout "Dear Jesus"), and the second cut off her whole neck, leaving only some muscles, and then the executioner sawed them off with an axe. Some reports say that the death penalty actually needs a third strike.

When the priest replied to Mary's letter from Scotland, he used a modern quill pen with a ballpoint pen. In this film, Princess Isabella Clara Eugenia of Spain is regarded as a young child. However, during the Alamada period, she was 19 (1585) and 2 1.

Walter Raleigh did not participate in the attack on the Armada. 1588, he was in Ireland and fell out of favor with Elizabeth I.

It was Francis Drake who organized the fireboat attack and dispersed the Spanish Armada. Beth Slockmorton's pregnancy didn't happen until the summer of 159 1, that is, three years after the Spanish Armada.

Elizabeth didn't know she was pregnant at that time, and it was not until the next year, a few months after their child Dameire was born, that she discovered that Rowley and Beth were secretly married. Soon after, while Rowley was imprisoned in the Tower of London, the baby died.

In the movie, Elizabeth found that Beth and Raleigh had been close before 1588 Armada. In fact, she didn't find it until 1592.

At the end of "Queen Elizabeth", Elizabeth called william cecil "Queen Elizabeth". Although he was not described in "The Golden Age of Queen Elizabeth", he was actually a close adviser to the Queen. Although not depicted, robert dudley (played by joseph fiennes in Elizabeth) was the commander-in-chief of the British army during the invasion of the Armada.

Mary was basically brought up in France and speaks with a French accent, not a Scottish accent. The Battle of Fireships took place on the French coast, not in England.

Elizabeth was riding a horse when she gave a speech to the army.