Current location - Music Encyclopedia - Chinese History - What are the plots in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms that are inconsistent with history?
What are the plots in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms that are inconsistent with history?
The story of the old fairy in South China is not true. It is probably made up by Zhang Jiao.

In history, there are no three sworn relationships in Taoyuan, only that He Zhang is Liu Bei's brother.

Guan Yu's weapon is not "Dragon Crescent Moon Blade"; Zhang Fei's is not an eight-legged snake spear, but a spear. It is not clear whether there is an "eight-legged snake spear".

Ada has never been a secretariat of Youzhou. Liu, Guan and Zhang's volunteers only defected to Zou Jing, a captain, and only lived in Hebei and Shandong, and did not participate in the battles of Yingchuan and Wan.

Zhang Jiao's three brothers don't know magic, but they can only recite spells and so on.

Zhang Bao was not killed by Yan Fu, but died in battle.

It was not Zhang Fei who whipped Du You, but Liu Bei.

The stories of Sun Jian, Dong Zhuo and Yao Zhang Qu's westward expedition to Han Sui and Bianzhang were cut out from the romance. Later, Han Sui surrendered and Bian Zhang died. Dong Zhuo stayed in the west of the town, and Sun Jiannan recruited Changsha thieves.

Lu Bu is not Ding Yuan's adopted son. And Ding Yuan is the secretariat of Bing, in Shanxi, not Jingzhou. And Lu Bu is the main book (civil history) under Ding Yuan's account, not a person.

There is no record in history that Cao Cao gave Guan Yu a red horse. (It should be "Tu", not "Rabbit" of White Rabbit. )

The assassination of Dong Zhuo did happen in history, but the assassin was not Cao Cao, but a bunch of scribes such as He Qing and Xun You. Unfortunately, the plan was leaked and he was arrested and imprisoned.

Cao Cao fled to Zhongmou and was released by a Gongcao of Zhongmou (whose name is unknown). Whether Chen Gong is unknown or not is unknown.

Unofficial history recorded the killing of Lv Boshe by Cao Cao. I don't know the truth.

Governors in more than ten towns begged Dong, namely, the late generals Yuan Shu, Jizhou Mu Hanfu, Yuzhou secretariat Kong Zhou, Yanzhou secretariat Liu Dai, Hanoi satrap Wang Kuang, Bohai satrap Yuan Shao, satrap Zhang Miao, Guangling satrap Juck Zhang, satrap Qiao Huan, satrap and Hebei North Phase Bao Xin. There are no four towns: Gongsun Zan, Kong Rong, Tao Qian and Marten. Cao Cao, the general of Fenwu at that time, and Sun Jian, the satrap of Changsha, were just small forces in the Eastern Alliance. The so-called warm wine to cut Hua Xiong, the three British war against Lu Bu is not a bad thing. Among more than a dozen allied forces, only Cao Cao and Sun Jian really confronted Dong. Dong Zhuo only fought Cao Cao after moving the emperor's people, and was not pursued by Cao Cao. Xia Houdun didn't kill Xu Rong. Sun Jian joined the army after Jun's defeat. It was defeated by Hua Xiong at first because Yuan Shu didn't allocate food and grass. Later, he cheated Hua Xiong and won a winning streak with Hu Zhen and Lu Bu. Finally, he fought alongside Dong Zhuo in Yang Yang and was in charge of his own Xiao Qi. He confronted Dong Zhuo one-on-one and defeated Zhuo Jun. Dong Zhuo burned Luoyang on his way to escape.

Sun Jian crusaded for Liu Biao, but Sun Ce didn't accompany him.

Zhaoyun defected to Gongsun Zan, never went to the battlefield again, and then returned to his hometown with his brother's funeral.

Gong was not killed by Yuan Shao's assassin, but by his brother who ordered him to help Yuan Shu's enemy Yuan Shi. The winner of the battle of Panhe was Yuan Shao, not Gongsun Zan.

There is no story of Diusim in history. Wang Yun killed Dong by taking advantage of the discord between Dong and Lu. "The Story Of Diu Sim" is a female post in the harem of Han Dynasty, and its position is far lower than that of concubines. Not some woman named Diao mingchan.

There is no such thing as chasing tigers in Dian Wei.

Guan Hai was not killed by Guan Yu, but died in the army.

Chu Xu did not compete with Dian Wei.

Xia Houdun was not shot blind in the crusade against Lu Bu, but before that.

It was not Zhang Liao but Seibel who cursed Cao Cao at the White House, so Guan Yu didn't intercede. But he has a good relationship with Zhang Liao.

Marten was not involved in the bloody clothes and letters.

Ji Ping did not poison, but died after participating in the rebellion of Ji Geng and others.

Guan Yu killed Yan Liang, but Guan Yu didn't kill Wen Chou. In the history of the Three Kingdoms, the only person known as the enemy of ten thousand people is related to Zhang. It is very likely that even Lu Bu is slightly inferior to it.

Zhao Yun met Liu Bei in Yecheng, but there was no Pei Yuan Shao.

Guan Yu's passing five customs and beheading six generals is pure fiction.

In the ancient city, there was no such thing as Guan Yu beheading Cai Yang, and there was no such person as Zhou Cang.

Sun Ce died in an assassin's attack, and there is nothing to lose.

Liu Bei joined forces with Cao Cao in Runan, and was killed in the battle of harassing Cao Cao to move the capital. And Gong Dou didn't die in the end, just disappeared.

Cai Yang died in the crusade against Liu Bei, in which the Battle of Bowangpo took place. The Battle of Bowangpo was initiated by Liu Bei rather than Cao Cao. Xia Houdun only pursued Liu Bei when withdrawing troops, only to be defeated and flee. At this time, Zhuge Liang was still in Longzhong.

Cao Cao's northern expedition to Yuan was basically consistent with the official history, but "Guo Jia's will decided Liaodong" was false, and it was Cao Cao's own idea.

Si Mahui is an "ice mirror",> mistaken for a "water mirror".

There is no official record of Ma Lu taking Liu Beiyue to Tanxi.

Zhuge Liang is by no means a scholar who has no strength to tie a chicken. Later, on the battlefield of the Northern Expedition, he only rode his bike and feather fan for the last time, just to lure Sima Yi into the war. In love novels, he wrote this only to deify him.

Wen Pin didn't have Wei Yandou in Xiangyang.

Zhao Yun, the rescuer of Changbanpo, protected Mrs. Gan, not Mrs. Mi. There was no such thing as Mrs. Gan jumping into a well. So, Zhao Yun held Mrs. Gan and broke through Nagano, and met the butch riding in Cao Chunli. Zhaoyun didn't meet Cao Cao, so there is no such thing as stabbing in the back, but Zhaoyun is certainly not as brave and invincible as the romance says.

There is no such thing as Liu Bei wrestling.

Zhang Fei drank Cao Jun in Changbanqiao, which didn't frighten people to death, but Cao Jun was also shocked by his strength.

Xu Shu's mother was robbed by Cao Jun in the disorderly army, and Xu Shu had to leave Liu Bei for Cao Cao, and her mother did not commit suicide.

Zhou Yu is not a narrow-minded person. Breaking Cao Cao is Zhou Yu's strategy. Lu Su is not a "loyal minister", but a very talented politician. For the fledgling Zhuge Liang, it is more important to learn from them.

Battle of Red Cliffs does, but many events written in romance novels are semi-related. Zhou said that after Battle of Red Cliffs and Jiang Gan lobbied Zhou Yu, there was no gathering of heroes. Cai Mao and Zhang Yunyou rebelled against Cao Cao and were killed by Cao Cao. It was Cao Cao's own idea to serialize warships. There is no such thing as a straw boat borrowing an arrow. It was not Kan Ze who threw the book to Cao Cao. Cao Cao's poems did not assassinate Liu Fu. The idea of borrowing Dongfeng is pure fiction. There is no such thing as an arrow in Huang Gai in Battle of Red Cliffs. Cao Cao defeated Huarong Road, laughing at Zhou Yu's incompetence and Liu Bei's dullness. By the time Liu Bei's pursuers arrived, Cao Cao had gone far and won only some grain and grass.

Liu Bei did not take Jingzhou by accident, but first took four counties in Jingnan according to Kong Ming's opinion, and the four counties surrendered without fighting.

Song Qian was not killed in the battle of Hefei. Taishi Ci died a few years ago in Battle of Red Cliffs.

The marriage between Sun and Liu is not Zhou Yu's honey trap, but a sign that the two sides joined hands for the first time to establish an anti-Cao alliance. Liu Bei resigned from Sun Quan aboveboard and went to Jingzhou without being hunted down. Since then, Sun Quan has lent Jingzhou to Liu Bei in full. After Sun Quan returned to Liu Bei, Zhou Yu died of an arrow wound. Wolong is not mourning.

Ma Chao did not send troops to avenge his father, but set out first. Ma Teng, whose father was in Xu County (renamed "Xuchang" after Cao Pi usurped the Han Dynasty to build Wei), was killed by Cao Cao.

There is no such thing as Cao Cao cutting his robe, and there is no such thing as Chu Xu naked Ma Chao. Ma Chao was frightened by Chu Xu and did not dare to move forward. Later, after Han Sui's army was counterattacked, it was defeated by Cao Jun, and it was not only Yang Qiu and the candidates who surrendered.

Zhang Song didn't recite Mende's new book. Zhang Song and Fa are the villains of the seller, but Fa is getting away with it. "If you agree, you can stay, if you don't agree, you can go. It is extremely despicable to honor the seller. " Therefore, although these two people, especially Fazheng, have made great contributions to Shu Han, Wuhou Temple has no place, which is exactly the case.

Pang Tong made the greatest contribution to the early stage of the surprisingly campaign. It was not Zhang who killed him in an ambush, but he caught Zhang Ren in an ambush at Yanqiao. Zhang Ren didn't want to serve the second master any more, so he was killed. Pang Tong was killed by an arrow at the front. Since then, Liu Bei has been trapped in Luocheng for many years-Mianzhu and other places have surrendered to Liu Bei at this time, not after the fall of Luocheng.

When Liu Bei captured surprisingly, there was no such thing as Zhang Fei's Ma Chao.

Going to the meeting alone means that Guan Yu and Lu Su agreed to meet on a plain. The two sides only brought a hundred warriors, so we cut to the chase and discussed Jingzhou. Neither side persuaded the other this time. Sun Quan did not send Zhu Gejin to recover Jingzhou, but directly took military action against Jingzhou. Worried that Guan Yu was outnumbered, Liu Bei went out to Sichuan for reinforcements. It was not until Cao Cao conquered Zhang Lu that he made peace with Sun Quan on the condition of returning some territory.

No matter how brave Zhang Liao is, it is impossible to break through Sun Quan's 100,000-strong army with only 800 people. Romance is exaggerated. And with the wisdom of Cao Cao, it is impossible to deploy only a few troops in Hefei. There may be 8000 people.

Ling Tong was saved by Gan Ning, and Chen Wufei died by Pound. At that time, Lu Xun alone did not have the right to command a hundred thousand troops, and Soochow could not have so many troops.

There is no such thing as Zuo Ci playing Cao Cao. There may be many fictional stories about Guan Ju.

When Liu Bei attacked Hanzhong, Zhuge Liang only played the role of logistics, and the chief of staff was Fazheng. Moreover, Ulan and Tong Lei commanded a legion alone, and they were defeated by Cao Hong when they debuted. Tong Lei is dead, so is Ulan. This makes it more difficult for Liu Bei, Zhang Fei and Ma Chao to attack Hanzhong.

Zhang Fei is not a reckless person. After Meng Touyan defeated Zhang He, he made great contributions on a piece of bluestone, and his brushwork was heroic.

There is no such thing as Zhang He attacking Jia Mengguan.

Han Hao is not Han Xuan's younger brother, but a Confucian general who is both civil and military in Wei. He once put forward a plan to open up wasteland to Cao Cao, which eased the grain crisis of the army.

There is no such thing as Yan Yan and Huang Zhong leading troops together. The battle of Dingjun Mountain was initiated by Liu Bei. Fa Zheng took advantage of Xia's impatient personality and led troops to pretend to attack Zhang He. Zhang He couldn't stop the attack of Shu soldiers and asked Xia for help. Xia immediately dispatched half the soldiers to save him. Huang Zhong broke into the village and hacked him to death with a knife. : reposting the Romance of the Three Kingdoms which is inconsistent with history.

Yang Xiu was not killed in Hanzhong military camp, but after returning to the Central Plains.

When Liu Bei proclaimed himself king, there was no such thing as "five tigers will lead an army", but Zhao Yun was indeed the most successful person in the whole Hanzhong campaign. Zhuge Liang also contributed to the logistics of grain and grass, but Cao Cao did not pay enough attention to it. For example, the grain and grass in Cao Jun were cut off by Zhang Fei, which had an impact on both sides.

Guan Ping is Guan Yu's parent-child, not his adopted son.

Pound shot Guan Yu in the forehead. Hua tuo was killed by Cao Cao a few years ago, and there is no such thing as curettage to cure poison.

Lv Meng died of madness, naturally not Guan Yu.

Guan Xing is not as skilled as the legend, but he used to be an official in North Korea. He died early because of poor health, and Zhang Bao died even earlier.

Liu Bei only used tens of thousands of military forces to attack Wu, because the total strength at that time was only 300 thousand, and there were not many military forces used except defending various places. Prior to this, Huang Zhong died of illness. So this time, except for the reserve army led by Zhao Yun, most of Liu Bei's troops were newcomers, and Sun Quan boldly used the newcomer Lu Xun as the commander in chief from the beginning, and led the first and second generation famous soldiers Han Dang, Xu Sheng, Pan Zhang and Zhu Ran to meet them, so he gained the upper hand in military equipment and general quality from the beginning. Zhou Tai, Ling Tong and others helped Sun Quan defend the northern front and did not participate.

At first, Wu generals Li Yi and Liu Ahe were equated with the defeat of the Shu army. Later, Sun Huan was trapped in Xiling. Wu Jun was defeated, but he didn't shoot Gan Ning, cut Pan Zhang and offer enemies. On the eve of Yiling, Lu Xun sent Xian, the leader of ethnic minorities, to lure the enemy-in addition, Moshako (wrongly written as "sand" in the Romance) died in a disorderly army, and there was no such thing as Zhao Yunshan's rescue, nor did Lu Xun's pursuit of the enemy in the Eight Diagrams (because there was no pursuit at all).

Although Liu Chan has no political talent and pursues pleasure, he is indeed a very clever man with a good popularity. Therefore, all courtiers like him very much. Coupled with the political ability of genius, he has settled down in Shu. There is no Sima Yi's five-way army going hand in hand.

When Cao Pi attacked Wu, Zhang Liao was not killed by an arrow, but died of illness.

There are stars such as Meng Huo, Kong Ming, Zhao Yun and Wei Yan. At this time, Ma Chao died of illness, and Wei Yan was in charge of Hanzhong, so Li Hui, Ma Zhong, Zhang Ben and others were used. They were also generals.

There is no such thing as surrendering to the Shu army, and the seven captures and seven verticals are mostly fiction.

At that time, Sima Yi was stationed in Jingzhou, and there was no such thing as Shu Han plotting against Sima Yi.

Kong Ming's first Northern Expedition should have only a few hundred thousand troops. It is also the strongest lineup in several northern expeditions. Moreover, only two of the six northern expeditions were Qishan people, and the other four were not.

Zhao Yun is probably in his early sixties, not a pioneer in the Northern Expedition. Therefore, it is a novelist's words that Mount Tai killed five generals of Korea and chased the enemy. (In fact, it is obvious that Zhao Yun's calm habit will not say "What are you afraid of before you get wet?" . )

It is a fictional plot to outsmart three counties and defeat Cao. Cao is really the second generation elite of Wei generals, not as incompetent as in the romance.

In fact, Jiang Wei's force is unknown-he has a high ability to command the army and is resourceful, but although he can't say that he can't, he can't reach the first-class level-otherwise Chen Shou should not be called "Wei Yong Guansanjun". Besides, he didn't compete with Zhao Zilong as he did in Romance. What Roche wrote represents the good wishes of the author and the ancients.

Walking in the street pavilion is Zhang He's masterpiece, not Sima Yi. However, one of them still took a big advantage of "Masu violating Ming Festival".

Although Zhao Yun's retreat from Qijiagu was not slightly defeated as in the romance, the loss of troops was minimal. I don't know that Cao Zhen's strength is several times that of Zhao Yun, and he can't beat our Changshan Zhao Zilong, so he will hang on his face.

It is likely that the "Table of Teachers" was forged by later generations, because Zhao Yun died after the third Northern Expedition (229), and Kong Ming was not so absurd that he didn't even know whether the North Korean general was dead or alive.

The second Northern Expedition in which Kong Ming really used Wei Yan Corps was the smallest of the five Northern Expeditions. The greatest achievement is to cut off the way home of Cao Zhen's chief expert, Xinmeile Co., Ltd. It's nothing for Jiang Wei to earn Ye Zhen.

The third Northern Expedition was mainly aimed at Wudu and Yin Ping counties. Kong Mingxian sent Chen Shi to attack the two counties, and then personally led troops to defeat Guo Huai, a famous Wei who came to rescue the two counties.

Sima Yi, who was attacked by Wei Bing, did not go. Cao Zhen died of illness.

The fourth northern expedition is one of the five northern expeditions. Although the number of Shu soldiers is less than100000, they use new equipment such as wooden cattle and horses and profit and loss crossbows. In this regard, Cao Zhen's successor Sima Yi adopted the strategy of static braking, and the two armies did not engage in large-scale fighting. However, there were many people, but they didn't take advantage-Wang Ping once led 3,000 flying soldiers to defeat more than 10,000 military forces of the famous Zhang He. Sima Yi was ambushed and defeated in the face of the pressure from his subordinates, and Zhang He also died under the gain and loss crossbow improved by Kong Ming on the basis of the original crossbow. But the opportunity of the Northern Expedition was destroyed by Li Yan's false imperial edict.

The last Northern Expedition, the failure of Wuwei Bridge, and the burning of the valley above-Sima Yi made a strategy of persisting in the war after insight into Kong Ming's physical condition-finally dragged him to death. Talking about no stars. (Note: Huang Xu died of illness, not Meng Da. )

There is no such thing as Zhuge Mi murdering Wei Yan. Kong Ming never had the motive to kill Wei, but he still cherished him. Wei Yan has no intention of rebelling against Shu. If he wanted to rebel against Shu, he would not cross Hanzhong and try to go back to Chengdu to complain to the queen.

The wonders that happened in Xiangping City are all bullshit. Jia Fan and others should persuade Gongsun Yuan not to rebel.

Six years after Kongming's death, Quan Cong and Zhu Ran, generals of the State of Wu, attacked Huainan and Fancheng. At the same time, Jiang Wan, the general of Shu Han, was also a soldier, but Wu Jun was quickly defeated by Sima Yi and the tomb, and the military action of Shu Han was forced to terminate. A few years later, Cao Shuang led 200,000 troops to attack Shu and was defeated by Fei Yi and Wang Ping.

There is no such thing as Wang Kui's false surrender and the Eight Diagrams Array breaking the enemy.

Fei Xian was killed by Guo Xiu, a spy of Wei State, after being drunk.

Zhong Hui cut Shu and killed him without dreaming, only because his horseshoe got stuck in the mud and fell off his horse.

There is no such thing as a stone under a cliff.

Liao Hua was not a yellow turban insurrectionary thief, otherwise he would be 967 years old.

Du Yufa and Wu Xin were not killed but captured. According to the romance, Sun Hao often goes in and out of the palace with 200,000 fighters, which is really a failure. I'm afraid there are so many troops in the whole territory of Wu!