So we can only conclude that the suspect is Song Taizong Zhao Kuangyi on this basis? This is obviously not enough. It is absolutely impossible and dare not point the finger at Emperor Taizong in the history books, but it can still be seen from the analysis of inconsistent historical materials.
Du Taihou died in front of the couch? The real situation is obviously illogical!
Song Taizong probably knew that the legitimacy of his throne would be questioned, so all the history books were in his possession? A consultant? There's another paragraph below? On his deathbed, Du Taihou urged Zhao Kuangyin to preach to his younger brother Zhao Kuangyi? Great conversation.
"Continuing the education as a mirror" contains: After:? You and Guangyi were born to me and should be your brothers. It is a blessing that the country can establish a long-term monarch. ? Pu (Zhao Pu) signed an affidavit at the end of the paper, saying? Chen Puji? . His books were hidden in the golden palace, and he was ordered to keep them in the hands of the imperial secretary.
This is famous in the history books? Golden Chamber Alliance? , vividly depicts the feelings between Zhao's mother and son, pays attention to the overall situation at the orders of his mother, and finally passes the throne to his younger brother. In fact, we can refute this statement from the perspective of logical reasoning:
First, we don't rule out that Zhao Kuangyin is really a filial person, and she agreed to all the requirements before her mother, Empress Dowager Du, died. But what about this? Filial piety? In front of the imperial power, it is obviously not that important. Can Zhao Kuangyin find thousands of reasons to put this passage after Du Taihou's death? Covenant? Tear up, after all, in the feudal imperial society, killing brothers for power is everywhere, and it is obviously understandable to violate a verbal word.
Second, in ancient times, the inheritance of power and family property has always been a priority? Inherit your father's business? then what Brothers and sisters? . That is to say, judging from this rule, the only thing Zhao Kuangyi can inherit is the latter, but? Brothers and sisters? The premise is that there are no children, but in fact there are children, and they are two: Zhao He, 3 years old 1 1 Zhao Dezhao, 3 years old. Although Zhao Kuangyin's two sons did not meet the requirements of the Queen Mother? Long county? Yes, but at that time, Zhao Kuangyin was 35 years old, and Mrs. Du Can was convinced that Zhao Kuangyin would go away in a few years? I don't think parents would curse their son so much! Besides, Du Taihou is not a fool. Talking about Li Chu in front of two young sons before their death will obviously cause bad blood between them, which is not wise for the country and the family.
Third, let's look at the historical materials, so-called? Golden Chamber Alliance? It is also obviously illogical. In the feudal society of China, there are related records about the daily life of the emperor, and it is definitely necessary to inherit the throne. But what is puzzling is about? Golden Chamber Alliance? The important political event of Zhao Kuangyin's establishment as a monarch was not recorded in Mao Zhuan, but it was recorded in the History of Song Dynasty. What makes us even more strange is that Zhao Guangyi should have made the dialogue of Golden Chamber League public at the beginning of his accession to the throne to prove the legitimacy of his accession to the throne, but the fact is that this record was not made public until five years after his accession to the throne. Therefore, this gives future generations a reverie, the so-called? Golden Chamber Alliance? Could it be that Zhao Guangyi hastily acceded to the throne, in order to prove his innocence and build a political proposition? Therefore, from these three logics, there are problems in the origin and legitimacy of Zhao Guangyi's throne, which is one of the important reasons why he is regarded as a suspect.
Tai's ancestral home is in his brother's place? There are many contradictions in many historical materials.
Except the one above? Golden Chamber Alliance? In addition, there is a saying in history that Zhao Kuangyin himself intended to pass on the throne to his younger brother Zhao Kuangyi, which was vividly described by historians in the form of dialogue.
According to Song Taizu's Life and Stegosaurus's Legacy, Zhao Kuangyin summoned the Prime Ministers Zhao Pu, Lu Duoxun and others the day before his death. I can't afford this disease, can I? In order to arrange for them to handle government affairs in the future, Zhao and Lu agreed to put forward the problem of establishing Chu State. Zhao Kuangyin replied: "If I call a spade a spade, can I become the king of Jin?" ? .
Zhao Pu two people put forward? Your majesty's own son can be Chu Jun. How can you make Kundi your heir? ? But Zhao Kuangyin insisted on his decision all the time. He said, I've made up my mind. Your kindness has helped King Jin, so we can't talk about the establishment of the store? . The next day, Mao died and his younger brother Zhao Kuangyi succeeded to the throne. Soon after, Zhao Helu was dismissed because they suggested that Mao replace Chu Army.
According to this record, Zhao Kuangyin pushed his way through the crowd and passed the throne to his younger brother. They are brothers, and the transfer of power went smoothly. This is a quiet and touching picture. But in fact, the authenticity of this record cannot stand the test.
According to Zi Jian, in the sixth year of Tianbao (in 973 AD), Zhao Pu was abolished for harboring corrupt officials, and was demoted as our envoy to Heyang, a city far from the capital. On the day of Zhao Kuangyin's death, Zhao Pu was not in North Korea at all. How can there be admonition and the establishment of Chu? Besides, the so-called? I have this disease? What's the disease? Zhao Kuangyin, as the king of a country, if his health really has any problems, there will be relevant records in the history books. However, from the official history and actual records, neither the symptoms nor the cause of death are recorded in detail. The only thing you can see is the history of the Song Dynasty. The emperor died in the Hall of Long Live at the age of fifty? Short numbers.
In addition to the above two points, judging from the records before and after Zhao Kuangyi acceded to the throne, he is also the biggest suspect in Zhao Kuangyin's death:
According to the Song History, when Zhao Kuangyi was appointed as the King of Jin, he used to? Raise lux privately, make friends with martial ministers, and collect fugitives widely? . These practices will be regarded as existing in any dynasty? Suspected of rebellion? .
At the same time, as far as feudal social practice is concerned, the new monarch still has to use the old year number of the former monarch after he succeeded to the throne, and the new year number can not be adopted until the following year. But Zhao Kuangyi did not do this after he ascended the throne, but immediately released it? Tianbao nine years? Change to? The first year of Taiping Xingguo? This clearly reflects Zhao Kuangyi's inferiority to the source of its advantages.
Moreover, shortly after he ascended the throne, his two nephews, the best candidates to succeed to the throne, died one after another (one was forced to commit suicide and the other died suddenly for no reason). The death of the two of them can be said to have relieved Zhao Kuangyi's worries, but it is also one of the important evidences that Zhao Kuangyi was labeled as an illegal usurper.
In a word, Zhao Kuangyin's death is still an unsolved case. Through the analysis and reasoning of historical materials and events, Zhao Kuangyi is undoubtedly involved in the case at present.