Current location - Music Encyclopedia - Today in History - What are the historical mistakes in the TV series Sima Yi's Art of War?
What are the historical mistakes in the TV series Sima Yi's Art of War?
The TV series Sima Yi's Military Alliance (hereinafter referred to as "Military Alliance") mainly focuses on the magnificent life of Sima Yi, a hero of the Three Kingdoms, so that the audience can get to know this historical figure in a more active and delicate way. Wu Xiubo's personal charm also makes Sima Yi attractive, but it is precisely because of his charm that many viewers find that some plots different from history cannot stand scrutiny.

First of all, the time in the play is a bit confusing. Cao Cao entered the ranks of Gong Wei and Wang Wei at the wrong time in Military Strategy League.

According to the relevant records in the History of the Three Kingdoms, "In 2 13 years (the 18th year of Jian 'an), the Emperor of Heaven ordered Lv Chi, an ancient scholar, to observe the festival and made Cao Cao Wang Wei". Later, in 2 16 A.D. (the 21st year of Jian 'an), according to the Records of the Three Kingdoms and the Records of Emperor Wudi, "Emperor Tiandi crowned Wang Wei." So the time sequence of this main line is: Cao Cao became Duke of Wei (213)-Cao Cao was called Wang Wei (2 16). However, in the play, in the 13th year of Jian 'an (AD 208), Cao Cao asked Emperor Gaozu to make him Wang Wei on the pretext of being defeated by Sun Liu's allied army. Before that, Cao Cao had been called "the Prime Minister", which obviously contradicted history. According to the data, the prime minister system was re-established in 208 AD, and Cao Cao became king in 2 16 AD, which was the writer's mistake.

In addition, the drama also transferred the historical content about Jia Xu to Sima Yi.

Sima yi is the protagonist of the military alliance, but Sima yi's official appearance in history is not as early as in the play. Although the historical bosses Ma Yi and Chen Qun did form the "Four Friends of the Prince", which helped Cao Pi defeat Cao Zhi and seize the position of the Prince, Sima Yi's role was not as decisive as described in the play. Most typically, Sima Yi warned Cao Pi "not to disobey Zi Dao", which was actually taught by Jia Xu, a counselor of Cao Wei, not Sima Yi.

"Biography of the Three Kingdoms of Jia Xu" records: "At that time, Emperor Wen was a general with five senses, and the talents of Hou in Linzi were famous, and each had his own party and discussion to seize the nation. Emperor Wen asked people about the skill of self-reliance, saying,' The former general respected morality, devoted himself to the career of scholars, and worked day and night, which did not violate Zi Dao. That's all. It can be seen that "non-disobedience" was actually put forward by Jia Xu.

Finally, let's talk about the Xu Shao brothers mentioned at the beginning of the play.

The narrative at the beginning of this drama is as follows: At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty ... the Xu Shao brothers in Nanyang were famous and respected all over the world, and they often published comments on figures, poems and paintings at that time on the first day of each month ... People called them "Yuedan Comments".

Monthly reviews are very popular, no matter who they are, once they are titled, they are worth a hundred times.

Think it's beautiful However, according to the data, Yue Dan's evaluation is true, but the birthplace of the main characters is wrong, and the Xu Shao brothers are not from Nanyang. Ye Fan's "Biography of Xu Shao in the Later Han Dynasty" clearly wrote: "Xu Shao, the word will be general, and Runan people are also." Therefore, the Xu Shao brothers should be Runan people, not Nanyang people as mentioned in the play. Zhen Shi, Cao Pi's wife, cannot be called Zhen Fu. In fact, Zhen Shi's specific name is unknown, and there is no clear record in history. Why can't it be Zhen Fu? Because in the year of Huang San, Cao Zhi returned to his hometown after meeting the son of heaven, and wrote a poem "Luo Shen Fu", formerly known as "Ganzi Fu". It clearly says that the name of the god of waterinfo is Fu Fei, and Luoshen and Cao Zhi express their love for each other. Therefore, if Mrs Zhen's real name is Zhen Fu, it is not enough for Cao Zhi to have only a few heads. There are too many such things, which is understandable. Because the protagonist is Sima Yi, I don't think we can portray him too sinister and vicious, but we can only portray the characters as clean and kind as possible, but this is disrespectful to history. Sima Yi is an ambitious man, and his achievements have come out step by step, but he has done a lot of things to show that this person was not a soft-hearted person from the beginning, otherwise there would be no subsequent behavior of Sima Jia usurping Wei.

The alliance of military advisers tells us that it is not the same as the sluts on the street.

Under the signboard of historical drama, there is no so-called flow star, plus the "simplicity" of clothing and scenery, everything seems to tell us that this is a conscience drama. But it was not until the audience opened the bottle that they found that the contents had not changed, and it was still the ancient puppet wine filled with strong Jacques flavor.