I study history. This problem is tricky. But from a cultural point of view, it can be understood this way. Chu culture in the pre-Qin period is all-inclusive, with one dominant and many respected; Since the Han Dynasty, Liu Bang, a Chu man, has been carrying forward and inheriting Chu culture. The Han culture we are talking about today is actually a Chu culture with different packaging and soup. The first slave society that dared to challenge was the Chu people (Chu first challenged the Zhou Dynasty independently), the first to overthrow the feudal Qin Dynasty, and the last feudal Manchu Tatar was overthrown by the Chu people with one shot. It was also the Chu people who established the new China. There are many feelings of Chu in the articles and poems of Vienna. Although the Hunanese in Hunan, Chu and Hunan, which were successfully divided by the Qing Dynasty, had a lot of flavor in the past few decades, some stories finally happened under the charm of Chu culture. Therefore, there is a saying in the cultural circle: those who get the Chu plan, those who get the Chu are brave, and those who get the world. Just can see a thing or two about the pioneers of modern new China. (They are basically Chu people under the influence of Chu culture)

The recently published famous military book "Top Ten Commanders of Field Army" ranks the native places of 40 commanders, and the results are as follows:

The first field army:

Xu Guangda, a great general and a real father-Changsha, Hunan.

General Zhou Shidi, a famous iron army-Qionghai, Guangdong.

General Beard-General Wang Zhen-Liuyang, Hunan.

One-armed General He Hubei Songzi General

Honest and frank General Peng-Xiangtan, Hunan.

Hengge immediately-General Yang Dezhi-Liling, Hunan.

Warrior-Lieutenant General Zheng Weishan-Macheng, Hubei (now Xinxian County, Henan Province)

The main commander-Lieutenant General Luo Yuanfa-Longyan, Fujian.

Fighting in the North and Urging in the South —— Lieutenant General Liu Zhong went to Hangzhou in Fujian.

Northwest Hero-Lieutenant General Liao Hansheng-Hunan Sangzhi

Hunan 5, Hubei 2, Fujian 2, Guangdong 1.

The second field army:

Colorful General-General Chen Geng-Xiangxiang, Hunan Province

General Die Hard Rowen-General Wang Shusheng-Macheng, Hubei.

General Yong-General-Liuyang, Hunan.

General Chen Xilian, a famous soldier in the Central Plains-Hongan, Hubei Province.

The Road of Courage-General Chen Zaidao-Macheng, Hubei Province

"Sick Child" Warrior-Lieutenant General Wang Jinshan-Hubei Hongan

Commander of "Chitose Army"-Lieutenant General Qin Jiwei-Hubei Hongan

General Foguang-Lieutenant General Zhang Guohua-Yongxin, Jiangxi

The pride of steel-Lieutenant General Zhou Xihan Macheng, Hubei Province

The Wulin League Leader-Major General Li Desheng-Guangshan, Henan (now Xinxian County, Henan Province)

There are 6 people in Hubei, 2 people in Hunan, Jiangxi 1 person, and Henan 1 person.

The third field army:

The Head of the General-General Su Yu-Hunan Huitong

General Xu, a bloody and brave general, was born in Macheng, Hubei Province (now Xinxian County, Henan Province).

General Ye Fei, a Confucian general in the army, is from Nan 'an, Fujian.

General Zhuang-General Wei Guoqing-Guangxi Donglan

Both civil and military skills-General Song-Liling, Hunan.

Tough General-General Wang Jianan-Hongan, Hubei Province

General Chang Sheng-Lieutenant General Nie Fengzhi-Hubei Dawu

"The tiger is coming"-Lieutenant General Wang Bicheng-Macheng, Hubei

Desperate Saburo-Lieutenant General Tao Yong-Anhui Huoqiu

"Pi's meritorious service is less than Jinzhong" —— Lieutenant General Pi Dingjun —— Jinzhai, Anhui Province

Hubei 4, Hunan 2, Anhui 2, Guangxi 1, Fujian 1.

The fourth field army:

An indomitable soldier-General Huang Kecheng-Yongxing, Hunan.

General Qian-General Xiao-Changsha, Hunan

General Liu Yalou, chief of staff who chews foreign bread-Wuping, Fujian.

Cyclone Commander-General Han Xianchu-Hongan, Hubei.

The most dazzling general-General Deng Hua-Chenxian County, Hunan Province.

Both Wisdom and Courage-General Serina Liu-Xiaogan, Hubei Province

The main commander of the national army-General Li Tianyou-Lingui, Guangxi.

While the iron is hot, you need to be hard-General Liang Xingchu-Ji 'an, Jiangxi.

Commander Tashan-Lieutenant General Wu Kehua-Yiyang, Jiangxi

The darling of war-Major General Zhong Wei-Pingjiang, Hunan.

Hunan 4, Jiangxi 3, Hubei 2, Fujian 1.

There are 40 tiger generals in four field armies. Of course, there are more fourth field armies, but only the generals who can fight the most are listed. The total origin is as follows

Total: Hubei 14, Hunan 13, Fujian 4, Jiangxi 4, Anhui 2, Henan/Guangxi/Guangdong 1.

This completely subverts our previous ideas! I used to think that Sichuan people in Hunan could fight, but now it seems that Sichuan people can't fight at all. Except for the four marshals (most of them belong to political marshals, and their military ability is not strong, except Liu Bocheng), there are only/kloc-0 generals in old Sichuan, but none of them can meet, giving people a sense of top-heaviness. Among the top 40 generals who can fight best, there are 0 in Sichuan, which further shows that Sichuanese can exaggerate the war.

Hunan is ok. 1955, Hunan has three marshals, six generals and 19 lieutenants, but among the top 40 generals who can fight, Hunan has 13, ranking second, but basically in line with the fighting ability of Hunan people, but it is a bit reluctant to be called the first, at least from the ranking of the top 40 generals. Personally, I feel that many generals born in Hunan are very brave, but the generals who show off are also the most in all provinces! This is related to the personality publicity of Hunan people.

The most neglected thing is that Hubei people are also good at fighting. In the past, everyone said that people from Sichuan and Hunan could fight, ignoring people from Hubei. But now it seems that we are seriously wrong! 1955, Hubei had 1 marshal, 2 generals and 14 lieutenant generals, second only to Hunan. We can see that the generals in Hubei have the highest gold content. Judging from Lin Biao, the only marshal in Hubei, there is no doubt that Lin Biao ranks first among the top ten marshals in military capability. Even then, Lin Biao's military capability was far superior to others. Now some people put Su Yu, Liu Bocheng and Lin Biao together. Personally, I think the military capabilities of the latter two are not as good as those of Lin. Hubei people can fight. Judging from these 40 generals, Hubei people rank first. It can also be said that the military capability of Hubei people is absolutely not worse than that of any other region in China. But calling Hubei the first may cause a lot of criticism, because people don't know enough about Hubei's military strategists.

The second one made people outside Fujian province have no impression of Fujian at all. Now it seems wrong, it's time to rehabilitate Fujian people! Fujian people account for110 of the 40 Iliad, and Liu Yalou and Ye Fei are more famous. During Liu Yalou's stay in Northeast China, his military contribution should be the second, far exceeding that of the political commissar of the four fields at that time. He is Lin Biao's right-hand man, and is deeply loved by Lin!

There are also four people from Jiangxi, which is somewhat different from the general provinces in Jiangxi, because Jiangxi is the province with the largest number of generals above major general, and now it seems more unfair than Hubei.

There are two people in Anhui. Since the past dynasties, Anhui people have had a lot of experience in being an official, but few seem to be brave and good at fighting.

Henan is mainly Macheng, Hubei Province, and General Huoqiu of Anhui Province was taken away by Xinxiang County, Henan Province, which was newly established. For example, Xu is a native of Macheng, Hubei Province, and became a monk in Wutai Mountain. Until he made great achievements, the land where he was born was included in the newly established Xinxiang County, Henan Province at the age of 23, but the stubborn general claimed to be a Macheng native of Hubei Province until his death. Guangdong and Guangxi also each accounted for 1 person.