What are the mistakes in the TV series Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Water Margin that are inconsistent with history?

Category: Entertainment/Stars >> TV

Analysis:

The film is a great success, but there are many flaws when you look closely:

First, the scene of Cao Cao eating corn on the cob in the play is inconsistent with history. There was no corn in China during the Three Kingdoms period, and corn came from the United States in the Ming Dynasty.

Secondly, the middle-aged Liao Hua, played by actor Chen Zhihui, was a middle-aged general under Jiang Wei when Shu fell. This is really the makeup artist's mistake. It has been more than 40 years since Guan Yu failed in Maicheng and went back to Chengdu for help until the demise of Shu. I don't know if you have noticed.

Thirdly, the fact that the famous doctor Hua Tuo treated Guan Yu and Cao Cao successively in the film is inconsistent with history. According to the historical data found,

Hua Tuo (AD 145-208), AD 208 was the year of Battle of Red Cliffs. In the film, he scraped the bones for Guan Yu and was crazy about Cao Cao, all of which happened after Battle of Red Cliffs, and Cao Cao was imprisoned and died in the film. Inferred from time, it is inconsistent with history.

Zhuge Liang borrowed too many east winds, empty plans, Huarong Road and so on!

Some of them are based on a certain historical basis, while others are purely fictional, including the character and attribution of the characters, all of which are allowed by the novel. Seldom copy the description of history. If you copy history, there will be no Romance of the Three Kingdoms, only the History of the Three Kingdoms.

Zhuge Liang borrowed too many east winds, empty plans, Huarong Road and so on! The lecture room said that Chibi Station was also fake. It was Sun Jian who cut Hua Xiong, and Sun Quan who borrowed an arrow from the straw boat. According to the Records of the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei was straightforward. Both Che Zhou and Cai Yang were killed by Liu Bei, and Du You was flogged by Liu Bei, but the reason for flogging was that he was not allowed to ask for audience. Obviously, Luo Guanzhong distorted the facts in order to portray Liu Bei as a benevolent monarch.

Cao Cao was an all-powerful politician and strategist in the late Eastern Han Dynasty. He is a hero who is keen on eliminating all evils, helping the poor and reunifying northern China. At the same time, he is a bit treacherous and suspicious. In love, he became cruel, insidious and cunning, and his character was contrary to his preparation.

The worst is Liu Chan, who is known as the spokesman of the bad king. If Liu Chan was really an out-and-out bad king, he became emperor for twenty-nine years after Zhuge Liang's death. What is the explanation? In addition, Zhuge Liang and Jiang Wei's Northern Expedition got Liu Chan's approval, which shows that he is not the fatuous master who prefers Bashu and hopes for peace. Presumably to highlight the importance of Zhuge Liang!

Wei Yan's experience in Romance of the Three Kingdoms is seriously inaccurate. Wei Yan supported Cai Mao and Zhang Yun and killed Han Xuan. It seems that he is a man of temperament, straightforward! But he was able to appoint Liu Bei as the satrap of Hanzhong, guarding the 15th factory of Hanzhong, and not letting Cao Wei enter the customs alone. If he gets angry so easily, he will cut people with a knife. Cao Wei has no reason not to seize this weakness.

Cao Cao did not kill Hua Tuo.

According to the genealogy of the Han Dynasty, Liu Bei is a relative of the Han family, but he is not Xian Di's uncle.

It was Sun Quan who borrowed the sword from the straw boat, not Zhuge Liang.

The difference between the official history of the Three Kingdoms and the romance Many people regard the official history of the Three Kingdoms and think that everything written in the book is true, no matter whether it is true or not.

1. Taoyuan sworn: The official history didn't write three sworn brothers, only mentioned brothers (age: Guan Yu is older than Liu Bei).

2. Warm wine to kill Hua Xiong: The real Hua Xiong died by the sword of the Jiangdong tiger Sun Jian, and it is unfair for Sun Jian to write Sun Jian as the defeated soldier of Hua Xiong.

Yes

3. The three English wars between Lu Bu and Lu Bu were all repelled by Sun Jian .. (Gongsun Zan didn't participate in Dong Meng, so Liu, Guan and Zhang San didn't participate, so he didn't.

Hulao Pass and Lu Bu will have three battles. )

4. The princes of the 18th Route begged Dong Zhuo: Only the post-generals Yuan Shu, Jizhou Muhanfu and Yuzhou Cishikong? Liu Dai, Governor of Hanoi, Governor of Bohai Wang Kuang.

Only Yuan Shao, Liu Chen, Zhang Miao, Dong Jun, Qiao Huan, Yang Shan, Yuan Yi, North Hebei, Baoxin, Guangling, Juck Zhang, Changsha, Sun Jian and Cao Cao.

Thirteen families, Kong Rong was busy dealing with the yellow turban insurrectionary thief, so it was impossible to go to Dong in two places. Tao Qian only donated some money at that time and did not take part in the Battle of Marten.

At that time, he had not accepted the invitation, how could he join the ranks of begging for Dong? At that time, Gongsun Zan was about to deal with Bird Huan, so it was impossible to join Dong. As for JASON ZHANG, at that time,

Like Liu Bei, he is just a volunteer, and Liu Bei just follows Ka.

5. Chop Yan Liang and punish Wen Chou: It is true that Yan Liang was beheaded, but it was Cao Cao's subordinates who punished Wen Chou.

6. Zhang Fei whipped Du You: Actually, it was Liu Beigan.

7. Xuzhou killed Che Zhou and Gucheng killed Cai Yang: Liu Beigan did this.

8. Three things about Tu Shan: Guan Yu was defeated and captured in that battle, and there was no such grand thing as "three things about Tu Shan".

9. Cao Cao offered a knife to kill Dong Zhuo: Cao Cao thought that the final Zhuo would be defeated, and he didn't take Dong Zhuoqing to escape to his hometown ... Cao Cao offered a knife and didn't see the official history ... It should be fictional.

10. The serial stratagem: There is no record of the story that Lu Bu and Dong Zhuo of Diesim fought for a handmaid.

1 1. Guan Yu surrendered to Cao Cao: There is no special record, it should be voluntary (an important reason for Guan Yu's surrender in the third performance was to "protect the second emperor's wife."

But this is inconsistent with historical facts. According to historical records, after Liu Bei arrived in Xuzhou, he sent troops to order Guan Yu to keep Pi. Liu Bei's wife should follow Liu.

I am going to live in Xiaopei, not Xiapi. Cao Bing attacked Xiao Pei, Liu Bei fled in defeat, and his wife was captured in Xiao Pei, not with Guan Yu.

Surrender. In other words, when Guan Yu surrendered, there was no "second emperor sister-in-law" around him. )

12. After five levels, six generals will be killed: these five levels are far apart and have no connection. After Guan Yu left Cao Cao, he went south directly from Xuchang to Runan.

Liu Bei, there is no such thing as going through five customs and beheading six generals. )

13. Six generals beheaded: Sanyan will be Kong Xiu, Meng Tan, Han Fu, Bian Xi, Wang Zhi and Chyi Chin, and these people have never seen history books.

Alas, even the names are fictitious. There is only one task for them to appear, and that is to get a knife from Master Guan.

14. Sun Jian's death: Sun Jian died in Yanshan Mountain ... Because of riding alone, only a few followers were ambushed and killed by Huang Zu, which caused heavy losses.

15. Sun Ce's death: Actually, he was assassinated by an assassin (I rode alone on the way to attack Chen Deng, but it's more exaggerated ... I went alone.

Hunting ... Coincidentally, I was targeted by three famous guests of Xu Gong (Xu Gong died at the hands of Sun Ce), that is, Sun Ce Xiao Yong, but I was shot in the face and was deeply hurt.

Huang Gai and others later tried their best to rescue them, but there was nothing they could do.

16. Xu Shu's wisdom: Xu Shu recorded too little in the official history. . . Just an unknown passer-by

17. Xu Shu entered: Cao Cao went south, Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang and Xu Shu fled south, and Xu Mu was captured in the disorderly army, so Xu Shu bid farewell to Liu Bei and entered Cao Cao.

Camp;

18. Burning Wang Bo: Not Zhuge's, but Liu Bei's handwriting ... It happened in the seventh year of Jian 'an, and in the twelfth year of Jian 'an, Zhuge Liang came out of the mountain.

19. Mrs. Mi committed suicide by jumping into a well and digging a well in Chaoyun: According to official records, ... Mrs. Gan and Mrs. Mi were safe in Dangyang ... so they didn't.

Chaoyun knocked down the earth wall and built a well.

20. Seven in and seven out of Changbanpo: Zhao Yun escorted the family to a very dull retreat.

2 1. Roaring Changban Bridge: Cao Jun and Xiahou Jie were scared to death because of this = = || is an exaggeration in the novel. ..

22. Risk: There is indeed a case of Huang Gai pretending to surrender to Cao Cao in the official history. But the risk is questionable. ..

23. Debate of Confucians: There is no such thing as Zhuge Hui Sun Quan ... For example, the debate of Confucians, the intellectual stimulation of Zhou Yu, the gathering of heroes, risks and serial schemes are all empty.

Structure.

24. Mrs. Sun threw herself into the river: the marriage between Mrs. Sun and Liu Bei was originally just one of countless political marriages in history. Mrs. Sun went to Jingzhou. She didn't.

Liu Bei went to Soochow to get married. There is not much love between men and women here. When they got married, Liu Bei was nearly half a century old, but Mrs. Sun didn't.

More than twenty, the age difference is about thirty years old ... one is a fierce man who is eyeing up, and the other is a proud girl who is willful and distrustful.

How can you have sex? Therefore, shortly after Liu Bei entered Yizhou, Sun Quan "sent a boat to meet his sister", and Mrs. Sun did not hesitate to return to her family, and it was almost the same.

Took away Liu Bei's precious son Dou. Since then, she has never come back and never heard from Liu. It is a lie for Mrs. Sun to throw herself into the river.

There is no such thing. Where is Liu Bei? After occupying Yizhou, she married a widowed Wu (Wu Yi's sister, Liu Zhang's sister-in-law) and didn't see anything about Mrs. Sun.

Homesickness is precisely because of this, there is not a word about Mrs. Sun in the History of the Three Kingdoms, Shu Shu Shu and Biography of Empresses! Sun Fu is not recorded in the history books.

The final outcome of people, but what is certain is that she will never commit suicide for Liu Bei.

This poem (Sol Qiao) was written by Cao Zhi. . . It didn't show up at that time.

26. Zhou calculated Jiang Gan; Lobbying Zhou Yu after Chibi in Jiang Gan. . . . . No (Jiang Gan didn't convince Zhou Yu in history, so he came back to praise him.

Zhou Yu was generous enough not to fall for it, and so was Battle of Red Cliffs a few years ago. )

27. Pang Tong Serialization: There is no record that the serialization was Cao Cao's decision, and Pang Tong did not participate in Battle of Red Cliffs.

28. The grass "boat" borrows an arrow: There is no such thing. This was done when Sun Jian and Sun Quan were fighting Liu Biao and Su Xu respectively when crossing the river. (The ancestor of Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

In Three Kingdoms Pinghua, it was Gong Jin who borrowed the arrow. )

29. "Grass" boat borrows arrows: During the Anshi Rebellion in the Tang Dynasty, Zhang Xun used a grass man to hang down the wall at night and earned hundreds of thousands of arrows from Linghu Tide.

Supplement ...)

Comprehensive (20)(2 1) becomes a straw boat that borrows arrows.

30. Begging for the east wind: pure fiction (borrowing the east wind-the solstice in winter, with more southeast winds, is a natural disaster of Cao Cao, not a man-made disaster; )

3 1. Huarong Road Guan Yuyi explained Cao Cao: This was invented by the author in order to vilify Cao Cao and establish the tall image of Guan Yu. What intercepted Cao Cao in Huarong Road was

Liu Bei, but he went late, so Cao took Cao Ran away.

32. Battle of Changsha: Liu Beinan conquered four counties in Jingnan, and the four counties surrendered. Huang Zhong and Han Xuan, the magistrate of Changsha, surrendered without a fight.

33. Curettage of the Palace: At this time, Hua Tuo has been dead for two years, so it was not Hua Tuo's doing, and it seems that it was just ordinary military doctors.

34. Zhuge Sanqi Zhou Yu: Zhou Yu did not pay attention to Zhuge Liang at that time. . . Rarely meet ... During the two years from the end of Battle of Red Cliffs to Zhou Yu's death,

Zhuge Liang did logistics work in Lingling area and never met Zhou Yu at all. As for the death of Zhou Yu, the representative of Shu condolences is Pang Tong, and

Not Zhuge Liang.

35. Hanzhong: Liu Bei was the commander in chief at the front line of Hanzhong, and Zhuge Liang stayed in Chengdu to do logistics work.

36. Losing a wife and soldiers: a simple political marriage. . . . . Without him

37. Zhou Yu's death: Zhou Yu died of overwork in Baqiu.

38. Taking advantage of Jingzhou: Lu Su plans to arrive in Cao with Liu.

39. Marten asked Dong Zhuo: Marten and Dong Zhuo are both on the same team. Not only did they not participate in Dong Meng, but they also helped Dong Zhuo defend Chang 'an.

40. Ma Chao raised troops: In fact, it was a rebellion against his father (as for Ma Teng's death, Ma Teng did not seek to punish Cao Cao, and Ma Chao took revenge, but Ma Chao raised troops against him.

Cao, so Marten was killed. )

4 1. The strategy of taking Shu: Fa Zheng Pang Tong completed. . . . . . .

42. Zhang Song presented a map: After Liu Bei entered Shu, he wooed Fa Zheng and Zhang Song and asked about the grain, grass and money of the military forces in Shu, so Zhang Song drew "West Shu".

Topographic map.

43. Joe should be "Joe". He and Qiao Xuan are not the same person.

44. The story of Diusim: There is doubt ... but Wang Yun did have a maid who turned Dong Zhuo and Lu Bu against each other.

45. Liu Dai: There are two Liu Dai in official history. Liu Dai, who opposes Dong Zhuo's alliance, is not the same as Liu Dai under Cao Cao.

46. How old is Han Sui? In the romance, Cao Cao asked Han Sui how old he was, and Han Yi answered forty. This is wrong. At this point, Han Sui has been over seventy.

47. Guan Yu's Single Knife Club: According to the History of the Three Kingdoms? According to Lu Su Biography and Wu Shu, Guan Yu did not attend Lu Su's banquet, but went to Lu.

Sue went to Guan Yu's party, and the lonely hero who "went to the party alone" was not Guan Yu, but Lu Su. The three performances put the cart before the horse, and the "single knife" is the army.

The weapon of a scholar is a sword, not a broadsword.

48. Guan Yu and his colleagues: The relationship between Guan Yu and his colleagues is very disharmonious.

(1) Ma Chao: I heard that Ma Chao has joined the Party, but I refuse to accept it. I wrote to Zhuge Liang and asked, "Who can match Ma Chao's talent?" ("Reflection? horse

Super biology)

(2) Huang Zhong: I heard that Huang Zhong was a post-general. He said angrily, "People with courage will never be listed with veterans!" ("Reflection? Biography of Fei)

(3) Mi Fang: "Guan Yu and I are both satraps of Nanjun, but I like to be alone (personal relationship is not harmonious) and betray Sun Quan." ("Reflection? "Zhuolu Zhuan")

(4): "There is a gap with Yu, arise and oppose Sun Quan." ("Reflection? Yang "biography")

(5) Liu Feng and Meng Da: In the battle of Xiangfan, they were guarding Shang Yong, Guan Yu asked them to send troops to rescue them, and they stood by.

(6) Liao Li: Commenting on Guan Yu in front of Prime Ministers Shao Li and Jiang Wan: "If you rely on your brave name, you can't be an army. You can't help yourself."

Without discipline, it is simply subjective and reckless. ") (reflection? Liao Lichuan ")

(7) Pan: "It is also incompatible with Guan Yu." (Biography of the Three Kingdoms and Yang Xi)

49. Guan Gong and women: Cao Gong and Liu Bei surrounded Lu Bu, Yu Pi and Guan Yuhe, sent Qin for help, begged his wife and promised him. Linpo

And repeatedly open the public. There are different colors of public doubt, so I welcome in advance. Because I keep it for myself, I feel uneasy. In this way, Guan Sheng also had secular desires; About; In all parts of; about

The story of diusim is not recorded in the official history. After the death of Lu Bu, The Romance of the Three Kingdoms did not explain the story of Diusim. Most of the stories about Guan Gong beheading Sim under the moon are historical.

Economists think this is fiction. If it is true, Guan Yu is too unworthy to be a man.

50. Guan Yu was too frightened to surrender: Sun Quan persuaded people to surrender, Guan Yu pretended to surrender, planted a flag at the head of the city, retreated from another door, and was stopped by Monroe.

Kill it.