Current location - Music Encyclopedia - Today in History - What's the difference between Battle of Red Cliffs in TV series and battles in history?
What's the difference between Battle of Red Cliffs in TV series and battles in history?
The TV series Battle of Red Cliffs was adapted from The Romance of Three Kingdoms, and Luo Guanzhong's position in writing The Romance of Three Kingdoms was obviously biased towards Shu and Han. So when Luo Guanzhong was writing the decisive battle in Battle of Red Cliffs, in order to make Shu Han, the protagonist of his novel, appear, he substituted flowers and even made up many stories, forcibly adding a lot of scenes to Shu Han.

The TV series was filmed in accordance with the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and naturally these fictional deeds were also filmed. In the history of Battle of Red Cliffs, the Sun Wu family almost won. Liu Beijun, who joined forces with Sun Wu against Cao Jun, didn't play much role. In the whole campaign, Liu Beijun had little chance to play a role.

These stories, which were invented by body double, are the biggest difference between Battle of Red Cliffs TV series and historical facts.

Among Battle of Red Cliffs, Zhuge Liang is the person who makes up the most stories in Luo Guanzhong.

Zhuge Liang has two famous stories in Battle of Red Cliffs, one is to borrow an arrow from a straw boat, and the other is to borrow the east wind. Borrowing the east wind is purely original by Luo Guanzhong, while borrowing the arrow by the grass boat is a story with a historical prototype. It's just that the protagonist who borrowed the arrow was not Zhuge Liang but Sun Quan, who didn't take the initiative to borrow the arrow.

The real situation is like this. When the two armies of Sun and Cao confronted each other across the river, one day, Sun Quan took advantage of the fog on the river and personally went to the Wulin water town for reconnaissance. When Sun Quan approached Cao Jun Shuizhai by boat, he was discovered by Jun. Because of the fog on the river, Cao Jun didn't know how many Wu Dong warships came, so Cao Jun, who dared not attack rashly, took a boat and shot an arrow at Sun Quan on the river.

Sun Quan's boat is tilted because there are too many arrows on one side, and it is in danger of capsizing at any time. So Sun Quan ordered the boat to turn around and take an arrow on the other side. After nailing a large number of arrows on the other side, the boat gradually recovered its balance, and then the fog cleared, and Sun Quan ordered the boat to return. At this moment, Cao Jun discovered that there was only one Wu Dong warship shot as a hedgehog on the river, but it was too late for Cao Jun to chase it.

Another event that has a historical prototype, but Luo Guanzhong moved Pang Tong, a character of Shu Han, is the connection of Cao Jun's boat.

In order to create an atmosphere for the appearance of Pang Tong in Feng Chu, Luo Guanzhong wrote down the historical events of Cao Jun's connection with ships, which was a series of tricks implemented by Pang Tong after he went to Cao Cao on a pretence. Cao Cao fell in love with Pang Tong's plan and adopted a serial ship.

There is no record of Pang Tong working for Cao Cao in the Three Kingdoms. As for who put forward the idea of connecting ships in Cao Jun, there is no record in the history books.

Explain. In addition, the serial ships in the history books are connected end to end, which is not the kind of TV series that connects the ships horizontally into a Shuicheng village.

In the TV series Romance of the Three Kingdoms Battle of Red Cliffs, Zhuge Liang arranged a series of plots that Cao Jun was defeated in the Wulin and Luo Guanzhong forced Liu Beijun to add to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

Historically, it was purely accidental that Sun Wujun successfully set fire to Cao Jun Water Army in Wulin. Therefore, Liu Bei was not ready to defeat Cao Jun militarily, so it was impossible to intercept in advance. It was not until the news of Cao Jun's defeat that Liu Beijun began to pursue the defeated Cao Jun by land. However, because Cao Cao took a shortcut from Huarong Road and fled back to Jiangling, Liu Beijun did not catch up with Cao Jun.

Naturally, Guan Yu's release of Cao Cao in Huarong Road in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms can only be fictional. However, Huarong Road did appear in the History of the Three Kingdoms. This road is muddy and difficult to walk, and a large number of tired and hungry Cao Jun people died on this road. Compared with historical data, Huarong Road may be the place where Cao Jun suffered the most casualties in Battle of Red Cliffs.

In addition to Shu Han characters, some Cao Wei characters in history books did not participate in Battle of Red Cliffs. For example, in TV series "Battle of Red Cliffs" has been following Cao Cao, and Cao Wei's famous players are Yu Ban, Zhang Liao, Zhang He and others. They are still on their way to the Wulin camp, so they can't attend Battle of Red Cliffs.

Battle of Red Cliffs played in the TV series Romance of the Three Kingdoms is basically different from Battle of Red Cliffs recorded in The History of the Three Kingdoms.