Current location - Music Encyclopedia - Today in History - What's the difference between Daqin Fu and history?
What's the difference between Daqin Fu and history?
The popularity of the TV series Dafuqin made many viewers have a strong interest in Qin State and its history, and many people also learned about some historical events at that time by watching the drama. However, although Dafuqin was published in the name of historical drama, there are still many plots that are inconsistent with real history. Reading history books tonight, I will talk to you about some serious plots in Dafuqin that deviate from history.

First of all, Reese was beautified.

In Dafuqin, Reese became the minister of Ying Zheng, the king of Qin, very early. From the killing of Lao Ai and the attack to the unification of the six countries by Qin, Li Si participated in and assisted in planning all the major events that happened around the king of Qin, giving people the feeling that without Li Si, the king of Qin could not unify the world. In fact, before Qin unified the six countries, Reese did not make any special contribution. His highest position at that time was Ting Wei, the head of the highest judicial organ. Functionally, it is obviously impossible for him to participate in decisions based on military means, such as unifying the six countries. Don't think that Qin people are muddling along, and the division of responsibilities is clear!

In addition, in Dafuqin, Han Fei's death is portrayed as Reese didn't want his friend to be tortured to death, so he drank poisoned wine for Han Fei in advance. But the truth in history is that Han Fei saw that South Korea was unable to return to heaven, so he thought of Qin for a job. Li Si was afraid that Han Fei could beat him to the top, so he said to the king of Qin, "Han Fei is the son of South Korea, and he should think of South Korea in everything. It is a disaster to keep him. It is better to punish him with the law. " The king of Qin ordered Han Fei to be put in prison. Lest the king of Qin go back on his word, Reese immediately sent someone to send poison to Han Fei, forcing him to commit suicide. Later, the king of Qin broke his word and ordered Han Fei to be pardoned, but it was too late.

Of course, Reese is not without its merits. In fact, Reese is one of the most important figures in the history of China. To assist Qin Shihuang in making decisions and formulating major policies such as the county system, the book with the same language, the car with the same track, the unified measurement, and the unified currency. Under the influence of these policies, the concept of China as a unified whole began to take root in people's hearts. In this respect, it is not an exaggeration to describe the historical contributions of Qin Shihuang and Li Si in the future. However, merit is merit, and excesses are mistakes. It is a serious deviation to put all the credit that does not belong to him on him and wash away all the evil that belongs to him.

Second, the Lao Ai rebellion

In Dafuqin, the process of "Lao Ai Rebellion" was ups and downs. The rebels once captured the palace, and the streets of Xianyang were flooded with blood. At the critical moment, thanks to Wang Jian, a famous soldier, and the people of Daqin joined the counter-insurgency team spontaneously, the army and the people finally defeated the rebels in Laoai, ensuring the safety of Daqin's mountains and rivers. The record of "Lao Ai's Rebellion" in Historical Records is only like this: "Wang made Chang Pingjun and Chang Wenjun attack each other. In the battle against Xianyang, hundreds of people were beheaded ... others were defeated. In other words, Lao Ai and his followers were hacked to death and hundreds of people were defeated in the "Lao Ai Rebellion". If even a rebellion of this scale can crush Ying Zheng, the king of Qin, why can he govern the country? Therefore, Dafuqin's "Laoyi Uprising" was completely exaggerated.

Third, the death of Lv Buwei.

In Dafuqin, envoys from various countries went to Luoyang and invited Lv Buwei, an idle writer at home, to be the prime minister of their country. Therefore, many courtiers asked the king of Qin to kill Lv Buwei to avoid future trouble. The king of Qin couldn't bear it, and wanted to demote him to Shu, to keep him away from right and wrong, and to protect him in disguise. But in order not to make it difficult for the king of Qin to be a man, Lv Buwei simply drank poisoned wine and committed suicide. Is it true?/You don't say. /You don't say. The answer is: fake can't be fake.

It is true that the King of Qin ordered Lv Buwei to move the capital to Shu, but Shu was not a "land of abundance" in the Qin Dynasty, but became a backwater and a place to exile felons. If the King of Qin really protects Lv Buwei in disguise, will he be ordered to move to such a terrible place?

In Zi Tong Zhi Jian, there is such a record of Lv Buwei's death: "Wen Xin died after drinking zhenniao, and the burial was secret." People who give up their families to visit them will be driven away. "That is to say, Lv Buwei was secretly buried after being forced to commit suicide, not in the grand funeral of Dafuqin. Lv Buwei's family was not pardoned because of his death, but was moved to Shu, with a tragic ending. As the ancients said, a companion is like a tiger, what's more, Lv Buwei's companion is Qin Shihuang.

Fourth, others.

In addition to the above-mentioned plot that seriously deviates from history, Dafuqin still has some insignificant inconsistencies with history. For example, in history, Fan's Zhao soldiers were defeated by Li Mu and fled to Yan State for fear of sin, instead of fleeing in the "Lao Ai Rebellion"; Huan Kun, the general of Qin Dynasty in history, did not commit suicide in shame after being defeated by Li Mu in the battle to destroy Zhao, but was killed after being defeated in the "Fat War".

In addition, the monarch who was wiped out in Dafuqin was treated well by the king of Qin, leaving people with the impression that Ying Zheng, the king of Qin, was kind-hearted. But none of the six monarchs in history came to a good end. Needless to say, those monarchs who insisted on resisting, even Wang Jian, the monarch of Qi who surrendered voluntarily, finally starved to death. Good emperors in history are often not good people. Qin Shihuang is an emperor through the ages. Why should his descendants beautify his image as a good man?

References: Records of the Historian, Capital Tongzhi Jian.