They all took good pictures. The plot, acting, characters, scenes, theme music and lyrics are all high-level. Tang Guoqiang's Romance of the Three Kingdoms is my favorite. The scene is big, the characters are rich in expressions, and the theme song is particularly nice. It is magnificent and shocking. I hope to have such a high-level good drama to show to the audience.
Journey to the West is the most successful. Listen to me in detail.
What is success? People's acceptance, artistic achievement and inheritance are three points in the world.
First, Journey to the West has the highest acceptance. Among the four classical novels, Journey to the West was the first to shoot the TV series Change. When this drama was filmed, China had just started the reform and opening-up, and most rural families did not have televisions. The way for ordinary people to get in touch with new things from the outside world also depends on radio and newspapers, and the spiritual and entertainment life of ordinary people is extremely scarce. Once the Journey to the West was broadcast, it poked the excitement of the people of the whole country, and the immortals, monsters and ghosts in the book came to life. The characters are very simple, that is, two lines, one is exorcism by the Monkey King, and the other is seeking truth from the Tang Priest, which can be understood by most people and is highly accepted. In contrast, A Dream of Red Mansions, Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Water Margin have complicated relationships, numerous appearances and a lot of historical knowledge, which require a certain level of education. So people's acceptance is not high. In this competition, the score is 4 points, the journey to the west is 4 points, and the other three parts are 3 points each;
Second, among the four plays, Dream of the Red Mansion is the highest artistic achievement. The 87th edition of A Dream of Red Mansions has reached a peak in casting, grasping the characters' personalities, costumes, etiquette and music, and it is difficult for any other drama to achieve such success. However, A Dream of Red Mansions is an indoor drama, which is easy to shoot. Journey to the West is an outdoor drama. Under the difficult historical conditions at that time, it was not easy to achieve such achievements. Besides, The Journey to the West's music and costume modeling are excellent. In this competition, full marks are 3, Dream of Red Mansions is 3, Journey to the West is 2, and the other two departments each get 1 point;
Third, The Journey to the West has the highest degree of inheritance, from white-haired old people to naughty children. Who doesn't know Zhu Bajie and the Monkey King and who doesn't know Monkey King Thrice Defeats the Skeleton Demon? And in the past 30 years, nearly 3,000 replays are enough to make Journey to the West stand out. For the other three plays, how many people can remember Daiyu burying flowers, Battle of Red Cliffs and Song Jiang hugging? This competition, out of 3 points, 3 points for Journey to the West, and 2 points for each of the other three parts;
To sum up, from the analysis of people's acceptance, artistic achievement and inheritance, The Journey to the West scored 9 points out of 10, only losing one point, which is a well-deserved success.
The CCTV version of the four classic novels is successful, at least in characterization. Journey to the West and Water Margin are successful in all aspects. Although A Dream of Red Mansions is also very good, the age difference between the actors and the characters in the original works is too great, which makes people feel that something is wrong. There are two problems in The Romance of Three Kingdoms. The dialogue of the characters in the play seems to copy the classical Chinese in the original work, and the production of the martial arts drama is also relatively rough, which does not reflect the due momentum of the Five Tigers General "and one person defends it, and ten thousand people can't force it" ...
How to judge "success"? This is a matter of opinion. There is no uniform standard for judging, depending on the flow or the audience's liking, the economic benefits brought by it, or the people's benefit. I recommend a dream of red mansions, which basically respects the original work.
Journey to the West is the most successful!
Today, The Journey to the West is the most popular one.
First of all, in terms of subject matter, The Journey to the West can be regarded as the oldest drama in China, which initiated the fairy drama in China and brought people's eyes from the real world to the surreal world. No matter from the scene creation or the story, it gives people a refreshing experience. The first broadcast won high ratings, and then it was remake many times, which could not surpass the classics of the original drama.
Secondly, as for the audience, I believe many viewers have never seen A Dream of Red Mansions, Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Water Margin, but everyone has seen The Journey to the West, and they can never get tired of it. From dozens of years old to several years old children, they are all loyal fans of this drama, and they can kill all ages, because the story setting is more grounded, easy to understand and interesting. Unlike the other three plays, there may be no historical basis, so it is difficult to see clearly. It can also be said that Journey to the West belongs to the killing drama, and the other three belong to the historical drama.
Finally, the frequency of TV series is the most intuitive embodiment of the audience's love. Since childhood, The Journey to the West has been broadcast every summer vacation, which shows that it is deeply loved by people. In addition, the characters in the play are very successful and have their own characteristics, and related IP will also appear in various occasions today. And this drama is not without any meaning and reason. Adults often use: "If you want to get the Sutra, you must go through 8 1 channel difficulties for a long time like Tang Yan" to motivate children. The pain point in this drama is exactly what everyone will experience: there are always difficulties in life.
So on the whole, Journey to the West is the most successful.
Hello, everyone. I am a movie fan. I am very happy to share my views with you:
China's four classical novels are Water Margin, Romance of the Three Kingdoms, The Journey to the West and A Dream of Red Mansions. They also derived many film and television works, which became priceless treasures of China culture.
I think different people have different opinions on which of China's four classical novels and films is the best. From an artistic point of view, A Dream of Red Mansions is probably the best. But from the perspective of TV publicity, I think Journey to the West is the best.
Because I believe many people grew up watching Journey to the West, not a dream of red mansions. Although The Journey to the West's shooting is very rough and the technology is not developed enough, these actors look comfortable and never forget anything. Especially when we were young, this theme was very attractive.
Journey to the West is divided into three parts: the first part, 17, recounts the cause and effect of the Monkey King's havoc in the Heavenly Palace, which is the essence of the book. Tell the origin of Tang Priest in the middle, and explain the reasons for learning from the scriptures. Finally, the Tang Priest and his disciples went through 8 1 difficulties on the way to learn the scriptures, and the four of them finally made a positive result and brought the scriptures back to the Tang Dynasty in the East. The Journey to the West is regarded as one of the four classical novels of China, which shows its high status and influence. Through the artistic form of myth, it shows rich realistic content, euphemistically and skillfully reflects various social contradictions, shows the good wishes of all classes, the contest between justice and injustice, and the perfect combination of positive results and secularism. The characterization of Journey to the West has its own merits. The Monkey King's spirit of positive optimism and courage to struggle is an artistic summary of the long-term struggle life of the people of China, and it is the product of the combination of ideal and reality. Tang priest abides by religious creed and feudal etiquette, and does not distinguish right from wrong. He has changed from a eulogized figure to an object of ridicule. Pig Bajie's image as a small social producer, simple and honest, greedy and lustful, unable to tell the enemy from me, jealous and weak in struggle, is a deep excavation of reality. Friar Sand is unknown, single-minded, hardworking and simple, and has no regrets. It is through the different descriptions of different characters in the book that the fighting spirit of justice, fearlessness and courage is promoted, the evil forces are lashed out, and people are warned to recognize the essence through phenomena, be really good people, do good things, say good things and do good things, and finally have positive results!
It is precisely because the magic color of Journey to the West has been remake many times, and Stephen Chow's A Chinese Odyssey is all the rage because of its unconstrained plot and nonsense lines. Although it has been resisted and criticized by many mainstream media, it has also been greatly appreciated and supported by the post-80 s crowd, and it is also a classic.
So The Journey to the West should be the most successful film among the four classic novels. Do you agree with me?
Two bends seem to frown, and a pair of eyes seem to be happy. The state has two sorrows, and it is sick. Tears a little, breath slightly. In leisure, it shines like a beautiful flower on the water, while in action, it is like a weak willow blowing the wind. The heart knows better than the stem, and the disease is not as good as the west.
Hello, everyone. What is described above is the first encounter between Baoyu and Daiyu in Four Great Classical Novels's Dream of Red Mansions. Cao Xueqin's excellent writing style has attracted many lovers of the Red Chamber. Personally, I think the four classic novels of CCTV are very classic, but if you ask me which one is the most successful, I will answer CCTV 87' s Dream of Red Mansions. I believe there must be many friends who have different views with me. The 87th edition of A Dream of Red Mansions was a great success, and many stories behind it, the tidbits behind the screen and the life trajectories of the main actors were widely concerned and discussed by the audience and social media. As early as 1979, director Wang Fulin began to plan and study the script of the classic Dream of Red Mansions. 198 1 year, Wang Fulin had many exchanges with many scholars of the Red Cross at that time to discuss the shortcomings and improvements of the script. 1983 the script was finalized, and the national actor audition was in full swing. 1984, and finally 100 actors were selected from tens of thousands of actors. After two professional trainings, the TV series Dream of Red Mansions sponsored by CCTV officially started shooting in September 1984, and 1987 the TV series Dream of Red Mansions, which was expected by hundreds of millions of people during the Spring Festival, was piloted in CCTV for six episodes. As soon as the TV series was broadcast, it quickly became popular. Overseas Chinese groups in major media rushed to report, and hundreds of millions of red fans were crazy. Ouyang Fenqiang Chen's name spread all over the country overnight and became a household name. At that time, in the ordinary alleys of China, everyone talked about a dream of red mansions after dinner. No one knows Jia Baoyu, and no one does not pity Sister Lin. While the TV series A Dream of Red Mansions was successful, the original work of A Dream of Red Mansions and Cao Xueqin's life were read and understood again. At that time, A Dream of Red Mansions was once again affirmed by the literary circles because of the success of TV series, thus laying a solid foundation for the outstanding achievements of the famous novel A Dream of Red Mansions in China's literary history. For the above reasons, I personally think that the CCTV series Dream of Red Mansions is very successful, and its success is not accidental. Director Wang Fulin grinds a sword for eight years, Chen Ouyang Fenqiang's perfect interpretation of the characters in A Dream of Red Mansions, and the selfless dedication of Deng Jie, Li Ting and other actors are the main factors for the success of 87 Dream of Red Mansions.
The above is my personal answer to the question, which covers a wide range of knowledge. Personal views can't get a glimpse of classic works. Thank you again for reading. I hope my answer will draw your attention to the four great classic novels. Welcome to comment and leave a message, and I will definitely reply one by one as soon as possible.
It's all very good. I like 95 episodes of The Romance of the New Three Kingdoms.