Professional? Music fan? Everyone has the right to evaluate others, and there is nothing wrong with expressing personal opinions. But who gets the professional title? Is it recognized by the public? What our country is most in need of are people who claim to be “professionals” and “experts.” Nowadays, network information is so developed that anyone can directly participate in any discussion. If there is not a considerable proportion of recognition, then your "professional" is no longer a "professional".

Shuimu Nianhua spread throughout the country more than ten years ago. Personally, I think the academic qualifications alone are admirable. Besides, their music really influenced many people. My college days were also marked by Shuimu Nianhua, and I also liked their works. It’s understandable if you gain weight as you age. The work is greasy, I guess it was just a casual comment from the so-called professional music fans who were full of greasy mouths after eating a big meal!

As soon as the first episode of "Summer of the Band 2" aired, Shuimu Nianhua was eliminated. Not only did they encounter "a round trip", but they were also criticized by a 23-year-old "professional music critic" for the middle-aged man who was "too greasy" and "unyouthful".

To this end, Shuimunianhua Miao Jie responded. He admitted that he was indeed quite old. But he also admitted that they still have courage and passion.

In yesterday's program, Shuimunianhua sang "Goodbye Youth". It was a very popular and enjoyable song, especially the last part "Ah Goodbye Youth", which really gave people a feeling of "the years are passing by" , the feeling that youth never grows old; time is gone, passion lasts forever.”

Although they have reached middle age, they are still exploring and working hard in the field of music. This spirit of persistence in music, this courage and passion for music are worthy of respect and learning by young musicians.

Some people who think they are professionals, if you want to be unconventional and show your sense of existence, you have done it, but I think you are talking nonsense and lying without conscience. Have you really listened to their songs? ? Except for "With You in My Life"!

They are one of the best groups on this stage, but you killed them in the first round. They left this stage, which is unfair to the program and the fans! Are you suffering from a conscience? Speaking of greasy, OMG! You fat head and big ears! Speaking of which, I am also drunk!

Can’t you have courage and passion when you are older? Music cannot be divided by age. The youth of Shuimu is really the youth of a generation.

Although they have reached middle age, they are still exploring and working hard in the field of music. This spirit of persistence in music, this courage and passion for music are worthy of respect and learning by young musicians. Maybe some people are professionals, but most of them are bullshit...

I watched the first season of Summer of Bands last year and know some good bands. Collect some good songs to accompany me throughout the summer. Of course I will watch the second season this year...

Since the competition has rules, elimination is normal. If you choose to come to the band in the summer, you will face the judgment of others. It gives others the right to choose, and you are afraid of encountering people who are pretending to be calves, and you are given professional music fans who think others don’t understand and think they are awesome...

As for Shuimunianhua being eliminated, it is a feeling of unwillingness. As non-professionals, the team felt that Shuimunianhua's performance throughout the game was indeed not as good as before. After all, he has gone through the baptism of time and is no longer the boy he once was...

Compared to Shuimunianhua who was eliminated , the Brick-moving Team feels more sorry for the Wutiao people. Firstly, I prefer songs with dialect tones (such as Yao Shisan). Secondly, PeopleSoft is really funny, and I feel that the chance of the Wutiao people being resurrected is very high... < /p>

I have always believed that there are no professionals in the music industry.

Everyone’s life is different,

Everyone’s feelings about music are also different.

Some professionals may be able to analyze the structure of music,

Some ordinary people may have the experiences sung in the song.

What is the value of a song?

Is it just for some so-called professionals to show off their skills?

I think as long as the emotions are the same as mine,

A song that can make you sing,

That’s a good song,

There is no need for professional judgment,

every listener,

can tell the value of music.

In the past, there was a saying of "relying on the old and selling the old", which means relying on one's age to show off one's seniority and look down on others. This 23-year-old so-called "professional music fan" relied on his young age to not comment on music professionalism. Instead, he equated middle age with greasiness and voted based only on personal preferences. It is really unobjective. , is an obvious "rely on small things and sell small things". From this point of view, even if it is affirmed by these professional music fans, it may not necessarily be liked by the audience. Their personal subjectivity is too strong.

Today's young people don't know much about Shuimu Nianhua. The only song I can name is "With You in My Life". At that time, Shuimu Nianhua was still Li Jian and Lu Gengxu. Although the current group has changed people and I haven't seen them perform for many years, as an ordinary listener, this is the first time I heard this song "Goodbye Youth". I think it sounds good. I don't know professional music knowledge, but It’s just a simple auditory experience, just listening to a song, there’s no need to be so fancy.

Comments from young "professional music fans": One side thinks it's greasy, the other side feels that a forty-year-old should not sing "Goodbye Youth", and feels that this kind of music is outdated and unpleasant to listen to. But are old songs really bad? Take a look at how many of the songs saved on your mobile phones are still the ones you listened to in the early years. Are they still singers like Beyond, Jay Chou, JJ Lin, Mayday, Stefanie Sun, and Jingru Liang? It’s not that I reject new songs nowadays, I simply think that the songs nowadays may not be as good as before.

However, there are still young musicians who hold a different attitude. I also agree that music should not be differentiated by age. Music is also a way for people to express their emotions. Just sing about your own experiences and feelings. There is nothing wrong with it. Whether a song should be sung or not has nothing to do with age. Just imagine if it was Beyond on the stage singing "Boundless Seas and Sky" or "Glory Days", can you say their songs are outdated? Obviously impossible.

Finally, I want to say that as a professional music critic, you should bring some professional comments to the audience like Zhang Yadong, be more objective, popularize some music knowledge to the audience, and select more people to Recognized quality music.

Who is Shuimunianhua? I guess he is from a foreign country. Who is a professional music fan? I have never heard of him.

How to look at it, I feel that the evaluation is biased. If it is arranged by the script, it can only be said to be bullying. The songs of Shuimunianhua were sung by many people, and some even became classics. This group originally included Li Jian and Lu Gengshu, and the melody of "With You in My Life" can still be sung by some people. Although Li Jian finally left the band to reorganize, it is undeniable that the band left a strong mark on the music scene.

As a veteran band, Shuimunianhua is finding it increasingly difficult to survive in today's market, so it has no choice but to participate in "Le Xia 2". Even a band that sings youth songs should pay attention If you ignore the market demand and just keep doing things, a band that is out of touch with the public environment will be eliminated sooner or later. Just like Lin Zhiying, he had been singing "Seventeen Years Old Rainy Season" before, but later he realized the problems and stopped singing it so much.

In the show this time, the music critic said that Shuimunianhua was greasy. I personally think that was a bit too much. Maybe the description of the song style they chose was not suitable for the band. As a veteran in the music industry, I believe that it must be hard for them to be criticized by music fans rather than being criticized by peers in the industry. However, to participate in a program, you must have the awareness to face various voices, just like when Zhou Xun played the role of a girl before, There was also a lot of criticism, so it can be said that the music critic overrated, but it cannot be said that what he said was wrong.

Anyway, it’s quite uncomfortable to listen to. There’s no respect at all. Instead of commenting from a “professional” perspective, I just talk about my own subjective feelings. It’s strange that such a person can become a “professional” musician. Criticize people?