As far as official history is concerned, of course Zhou Yu is better than Brother Zhu for the following reasons:

Political talent: After Sun Ce raised his army, Zhou Yu, Lu Su, Zhang Zhao and others managed the rear and raised grain. Recruiting troops provided strong guarantee and support for Sun Ce to dominate Jiangdong. After Sun Ce's death, Zhou Yu was basically only in charge of military affairs, but his efforts to dissuade Sun Quan from sending hostages, and to join forces with Liu to fight against Cao all showed his political vision. After Zhu Ge followed Liu Bei, he basically managed logistics in the early stage, and served as the prime minister's pacification of the people ( Attack the heart first to stabilize the Southern Barbarians) and quickly stabilize the unfavorable situation of Liu Bei's defeat. The two people's political talents are basically about the same, but considering Brother Zhu's great achievements and influence in pacifying the Southern Barbarians, Brother Zhu is slightly better;

Military talents: Zhou Yu and Sun Ce pinged Jiangdong in the early period, and defeated Cao Cao in Chibi in the later period. He is known as a famous general throughout the ages; Brother Zhu went out to Qishan six times, working in vain and wasting national power, leaving hidden dangers for the final defeat of Shu Han; comparing the two, Zhou Yu wins;

Strategic vision: Zhou Yu offered advice to Sun Quan "Liu Bei was placed under house arrest, occupied Jingzhou, marched into Bashu, and stood side by side with Cao Cao" (unfortunately, Sun Quan did not listen); Brother Zhu is the "Longzhong pair" who divides the world into three parts; comparing the two, they are tied;

Knowing people Talent: Zhou Yu successively recommended Lu Su, Gan Ning and other capable ministers and generals, all of whom were Sun Wu's capable men; Zhu Ge basically did not recommend any great talents, and later used Ma Su, which led to the defeat of Jieting and the failure of the Northern Expedition; comparison of the two , Zhou Yu wins;

Magnificence and magnanimity: According to the official history, Zhou Yu's "magnificent temperament" and "real genius" even impressed a veteran like Cheng Pu; Brother Zhu informed Peng Yi and ignored Li Yan, which caused One is dead and the other is useless; comparing the two, Zhou Yu wins;

Literature and music: Zhou Yu's "music was wrong for Zhou Langgu", his musical level is quite high, and his poetry is also quite accomplished (unfortunately, it is lost); Zhu Ge's music There is Liang Fuyin in the above, and there is a master in literature (doubtful); the two have their own advantages and disadvantages, and they are tied;

Based on the above, Zhou Yu VS Zhu Ge, 2 wins, 3 draws and 1 loss, Zhou Yu wins