I think timbre and singing skills are equally important, one is indispensable and the two complement each other! Tone is the basic condition for vocal art, but if the singing skills are poor, it will be useless no matter how good the timbre is. It depends on the voice and timbre conditions. Without scientific vocalization, the songs that cannot be sung will have no beauty.

Intoxicated Singer

For example, singing is like playing the piano, singing skills are like the level of the piano player, and the condition of the voice is like the piano itself. Only high-level piano players can match high-quality pianos. Only in this way can the perfect effect be achieved;

High-level luthiers play high-level pianos.

Having a good voice but poor singing skills is like a person who cannot play the piano playing randomly on an expensive piano. Although the sound quality of the piano is good, the playing is nothing;

Beginners and Expensive Pianos

Good singing skills but a poor voice is like a professional piano player playing on a very poor and broken piano with poor sound quality, even broken strings and broken keys, and it is difficult for him to play beautifully.

It can be seen that singing skills and voice are both important.