The first leader of Liangshan, Shui Bo was not Classical or Song Jiang, but a man named Wang Lun. This man is a poor scholar, unable to say anything, but also narrow-minded, jealous of talent, Lin Chong was not less angry with him when he went up the mountain. How can such a person without a pattern hold those more than 1 vegetarians? Not surprisingly, he died.

2.

The second leader was Chao Gai. Before going to Liangshan, he was a rich man who loved to make friends. He was a brave man and made friends with Song Jiang. After robbing the birth class, he fled to Liangshan. After Lin Chong killed Wang Lun, he was regarded as the castellan with others. However, after Song Jiang went to Liangshan, the classical castellan was very embarrassed, because Song Jiang's name of benevolence and righteousness was all over the world, and most of the heroes in Liangshan were willing to follow him.

What's more, before going up the mountain, Song Jiang made many references of Liangshan heroes.

Chao Gai is honest and frank and simple. He didn't have any jealousy for Song Jiang because of his prestige in Liangshan, and he still regarded him as a confidant brother as always.

After Song Jiang went up the mountain, he always left Chao Gai on the mountain on the grounds that the owner of the cottage could not go down easily. However, he went into battle and led the troops to fight, made meritorious military service repeatedly, and accumulated higher and higher prestige.

Chao Gai is unpopular for another reason-he is not benevolent enough.

After Bai Sheng succeeded in outwitting the birth program, he killed an officer who kept staring at him, and was severely condemned by Gongsun Sheng and Wu Yong. Classical thought it was nothing to kill an officer, even if more than a dozen officers and men were killed, it was not a big deal. This sentence makes Gongsun Sheng and Wu Yong feel that he is not a good master.

Chao Gai is a man with little scheming and a very broad mind. But although he doesn't hate Song Jiang, he must be nervous about the present situation. Therefore, when playing Zengtou City, he must go into battle in person, trying to get back 1% for himself. But I never thought that I would be shot by Shi Wengong's poisonous arrow in this battle, and the poison would kill me.

3.

The third leader was Song Jiang. Song Jiang is famous for his benevolence and righteousness, and he is very good at employing people. Is a benevolent person who is good at employing people suitable to be the leader of Liangshan? I don't think so. As a leader, it is most important to think sincerely about what everyone thinks.

at first, sung river was just a petty official in Yuncheng county, doing some paperwork. After they went up the mountain, Chao Gai repeatedly invited him to go up the mountain to gather righteousness, but he refused.

Song Jiang actually has some ambitions in his heart. He wants to serve the imperial court and the country. Even when the classical Liu Tang wanted to drag him up the mountain, he said angrily that they wanted to trap him in injustice, so Song Jiang was unwilling to be a robber.

Later, after suffering a lot in the officialdom, he finally agreed to go to Liangshan, and changed the flag of Liangshan to "do justice for heaven", which became the name of benevolence and righteousness.

But letting a person who doesn't want to be a robber become a bandit leader is doomed to be unhappy. Song Jiang is also a person who doesn't cry until he sees the coffin. It is impossible to change his dream of serving the country because of the ideas of many people. Therefore, Liangshan led by him will be a tragedy.

3.

So who should be the most suitable person to lead Liangshan?

I think it should be Lu Junyi.

First of all, Lu Junyi used to be a general under the treacherous court official Tong Guan, who made him a common people, so his understanding of the imperial court was very clear, so he would not have illusions about the imperial court like Song Jiang and would not persuade Liangshan heroes to woo him.

Secondly, Lu Junyi is very loyal and benevolent. No matter what happens, he won't handle it emotionally, so he won't kill innocent people like Classical.

Thirdly, Lu Junyi used to be a famous general in the imperial court. His martial arts and reputation are very famous all over the world. Such a person leading Liangshan is equivalent to having a strong backer and is very secure.

although he has no popular support in Liangshan for the time being, it is because people have never known him well before and have never seen his ability. Liangshan heroes are all capable of speaking, so as long as he is given a chance, he can completely convince Liangshan people.

speaking of which, I suddenly feel that the tragic ending of Liangshan can't be blamed by others at all, but the blind worship of Song Jiang by Liangshan heroes.

4.

In fact, looking at the whole drama, I think Song Jiang is really unfit to be a leader. First of all, he doesn't have any martial arts or wisdom. Every time he fights, Wu Yong helps him with advice.

on the issue of Liangshan's most important way out, he acted arbitrarily. He felt that as long as he could serve the imperial court and be famous for later generations, even if all his brothers died with him at the hands of the emperor, it was an extremely selfish performance.

Only Chao Gai saw through him. The night before the war in Zengtou City, Chao Gai asked the three Ruan brothers if they would be welcomed by the court, but the three Ruan brothers said no. Before he died, he forced Song Jiang to take Liangshan brothers to the road of harness. Sung river said not to woo, what's the way out?

Therefore, after the death of Chao Gai, he did not pass on the position of the castellan to Song Jiang, but made an oath to break the arrow, saying that whoever could kill Shi Wengong would be the next castellan.

and that person is Lu Junyi.

However, all the people in Liangshan only serve Song Jiang. They blindly worshipped Song Jiang's benevolence and righteousness, but failed to see Song Jiang's selfish side, which finally led to the collective tragedy of Liangshan.

5.

I want to ask Song Jiang, "If you don't woo, where is everyone's way out?" Express your views on this issue.

the best way out for Liangshan heroes is to continue to be Liangshan heroes in the mountains. Because the treacherous court official was in power at that time and the emperor was fatuous, the court must not go. If you are good, you may be in the situation before going up the mountain.

so they'd better drink heavily and eat meat in chunks in Liangshan as they are now. Under the banner of doing justice for heaven, rob the rich and help the poor.

What Song Jiang is most worried about is that they will be branded as thieves and robbers forever. But in fact, they should know that the reputation of Liangshan heroes among the people is very good, and even has become a legend.

It is not the imperial court that has the final say, but the people have the final say. They can continue to do justice for heaven, leave a name when they do good deeds in every place, and when the court wants to destroy them one day, they will recruit soldiers and change the dynasty.

However, the premise is that Lu Junyi is the leader.

After all, Song Jiang is the only one who wants to get rid of the name of a robber, otherwise others would not be able to climb the mountain so easily. Most of them are just asking for a clear conscience, regardless of what others say.

Song Jiang can't do it. His idol burden is too heavy, and it happens that he is a blind worshipper, so the tragic ending is logical.

So what kind of truth does Water Margin tell us?

Too much idol burden, too much self-esteem, too much attention to false titles and blind worship are all great shortcomings that harm others and themselves.