Faced with the current situation that film and television works frequently joke about history, history teacher Zhang Guangqiang said in an interview that these works really caused some confusion to teachers. We should always emphasize to students in class that film and television works are only entertainment, not real history.
Teacher Zhang revealed that he and his colleagues will also watch such so-called historical film and television works, and it is not good not to watch them. If you don't read it, you don't know how to express your opinion in case the students ask. Teacher Zhang admits that such works will mislead students and confuse their historical views, and the impact on students is of course negative. It is true that students have discussed with us that the plots of TV dramas are historical facts, so now we all take the initiative to emphasize to students which plots in TV dramas are completely divorced from history. As a teacher, it is the responsibility for students to distinguish what is entertainment and what is history. I hope that through our reminder, we can guide students to establish a correct view of history.
At the end of this year, David chose the hit historical drama, and the historical theme was also reflected on the big screen-however, the historical theme mentioned here is also collectively called a joke, because they are only works based on historical figures, and the content is very different from the well-known history. For such film and television works, netizens who claimed to be half-baked in history said that they were unable to vomit and could only vomit blood. Many netizens even worry about the history teacher, whose heart can't stand it at any time! Wen, the actor of The Legend of Heroes in Sui and Tang Dynasties, quipped on Weibo: A friend who was studying history in corn vomited that he had to swallow several pills to lower his blood pressure before watching The Legend of Heroes in Sui and Tang Dynasties. However, the history teacher said in an interview with reporters that he was not afraid to watch these dramas. If he doesn't look at them, he won't know how much they have changed, and he can't tell the students in class.
No.65438 +0: Eunuch Debate;
Eunuch becomes chivalrous, Cixi becomes loving mother.
In tvb Taiqing drama "The Great Eunuch", two emperors, Li Yaoxiang, and an old opera player, Mi Xue, played Li and Cixi respectively, telling how Li went through numerous struggles in the deep palace and eventually became a celebrity around Empress Dowager Cixi.
In the traditional concept, Li is a sinister villain. He dumped power in the ruling and opposition parties, took bribes to interfere in state affairs, widely planted private parties to covet wealth and blackmail officials. However, in "The Great Eunuch", Li Qingzheng was honest and even named as a male version. At the same time, Cixi, who has always been regarded as overbearing and cruel, has also been interpreted as a loving mother who loves the country and the people. Coupled with the lines full of crossing, the audience really don't know where the legendary Empress Dowager Cixi who rejected her own son and tried her best to maintain her desire for personal rule went.
Moreover, The Great Eunuch also depicts that there is true love everywhere in the court, not only between eunuchs and ladies-in-waiting, but also between eunuchs and princesses, which makes the audience inevitably messy in the wind. I really want to ask the screenwriter, are you sure you wrote the story of the eunuch?
Netizen identification: tvb's skill in compiling historical dramas will even be inferior to that of mainland cross-country dramas. The famous villains with surnames in history have been washed away and become good people. All the children have to go back and ask the history teacher-why do you make these characters useless and everyone has to take the blame in class?
The play looks more like a palace except for the fence, which is basically not like being in a palace. Besides, there are only a few tvb actors coming and going, and the plot is described with affection and righteousness, which makes it easy for people to perform: didn't these actors all work as Hong Kong police before? Why did they collectively cross into eunuchs?
Second place: Sui and Tang Dynasty hero controversy: Li Shimin was born earlier than 10!
The Legend of Heroes in Sui and Tang Dynasties begins with a description of the battle to destroy Chen in Sui Dynasty. Interestingly, next came Li Shimin, who was already a teenager who was busy in love. However, the real history is that the battle to destroy Chen in the Sui Dynasty took place in February 65438 +588, and it was born in October 65438 +599 before it was born. Roughly speaking, Li Shimin was born by a writer more than 10 years ago!
In addition, when Chen Jun and Sui Jun were engaged in siege warfare, Chen Guojun was sitting in the palace enjoying the dancers' performances. Next, Zhang Lihua, a beautiful woman in Chen Guo, took off her palace costume and put on her uniform, and suddenly became a chivalrous woman with high martial arts. She also started a series of revenge actions lurking around the Prince of Sui Dynasty. Such changes are also difficult to calm netizens. Moreover, Chen Houzhu should have been captured to Chang 'an and died in Luoyang six years later, but the play gave him three feet of white silk on the day when Chen Guo perished. Moreover, Yang Guang's face is upright. He cares about the country and the people, and the princess runs into the street every day to try to be brave. This is a bridge that is hard for the audience to accept.
Netizen identification: Isn't the title "Heroes of Sui and Tang Dynasties"? However, what about the hero? Why not change its name to Sui and Tang harem? Although the scene is grand and the stars are shining, is this story really related to history? If the heroes of Sui and Tang Dynasties had knowledge under the spring, I wonder if they would come back to play screenwriters with spears and galloping horses?
Third place: Debate on the King's Banquet: A steamed bread made Han Xin abandon Xiang Yu.
Although the title of "Banquet of the Kings" immediately reminds everyone of the Hongmen Banquet, in fact, the Hongmen Banquet was compressed to only a few minutes in the film, and Xiang Yu's scenes were pitiful, like a soy sauce maker. In fact, this film is to recall from the perspective of Lao Liu Bang, and to present a series of processes of eliminating Qin in a fragmented form. Including the acquaintance with Han Xin and the encounter with Xiang Yu.
Although Lu Chuan said that this pattern was deliberately presented by him, some shots were unexpected. For example, the Chu-Han War was basically a sword-drawing contest for more than a dozen people. Xiang Yu has only a few guns to fight to the death, and Xiang Yu has no horse or gun. He swung his sword at random and cut it twice before he fell off. The famous Farewell My Concubine doesn't even have a line. She stabbed her heart and her play was over. ...
Netizen identification: Lu Chuan said in his propaganda that his film wanted to express his understanding of that period of history. However, many netizens don't know, is this understanding or misunderstanding? When Han Xin was young, he secretly protected Liu Bang at the Hongmen banquet for a steamed bun? For the sake of a steamed bread when he was young, Han Xin abandoned Xiang Yu at the peak and defected to Liu Bang? Lu Chuan said that this film has been carefully studied. Are all the experts who study historical records collectively amnesia?
Fourth place: Wang's woman controversy: Xiang Yu's true love is!
The costume drama "Wang's Woman", starring Luo Jin, Wang and other popular idols, has recently set off a Chu-Han craze.
The play is based on the hegemony between Chu and Han. However, perhaps because of too many changes in the plot, Xiang Yu's name became Yun Kuang, Lv Zhi became Lv Le, Liu Bang became Haitian, and Yu Ji became Miao Ge. Although the name of the protagonist was changed, the costumes in the Qin and Han Dynasties and the basic characters in the Chu and Han Dynasties can still show the traces of Liu Bang and Xiang Yu. However, in the setting of characters, great changes have taken place in the relationship between characters: Lv Hou became Xiang Yu's favorite, while Yu Ji was a scheming bad woman!
Netizen's comment: I didn't expect a screenwriter to arrange a * * * drama for Xiang Yu and Lv Hou ... What reaction can there be except being speechless? Probably only by completely putting aside historical experience or becoming a fanatical fan of an actor will you chase this drama like an ordinary idol drama. Or your head will be caught in the door!
Fifth place: The Battle of the Hongmen Banquet: Pipaxing? Play the piano!
Nowadays, costume films love to sing ancient poems and songs. In the movie "The Hongmen Banquet", Liu Yifei, a beautiful woman, also plays the pipa, which is really a bit nonsense. At that time, there was no pipa in China, which was introduced to the Central Plains in Wei and Jin Dynasties. The most surprising thing is that the pipa played by Liu Yifei is quite exquisite and modern!
Netizen identification: A historian once wrote that if you want to annoy a historian or history lover, the best way is to invite him to see a movie "The Hongmen Banquet". With this sentence, the rest is needless to say, right?
Main creative response:
Basically respect big historical facts.
Despite all kinds of bricks from netizens, the founders of these historical works are quite calm when responding to questions. In their view, they just made a new interpretation of history.
Wang Xiangwei, director of The Legend of Heroes in Sui and Tang Dynasties, said: The Legend of Heroes in Sui and Tang Dynasties is a drama that combines many elements such as history, legend and romance. It has history, drama and novels, so Li Shimin can appear early to make the drama more exciting. Although there are many adaptations, Wang Xiangwei thinks that heroes in Sui and Tang Dynasties basically respect big historical facts and don't go outside the circle. When talking about Li Shimin's early appearance, Ye Luo, one of the screenwriters of the play, explained: When I wrote the script, I wanted to take Li Shimin as the protagonist, so I let him appear in the first episode, which is really different from history, but after all, TV plays are works of art, and heroes in Sui and Tang Dynasties are also romantic works.
Facing the question of whitewashing historical figures, Marco Law, the producer of The Great Eunuch, insists that when we look up Li's life information, most historians know that he is a mixed-race person. We look at Li from the perspective of personal growth. Not for him, nor for subverting history, but for filling something in this blank history. As for Cixi, what the play wants to emphasize is that she is also the mother of others. After portraying Liu Bei as a soft rice, director Hu Mei also said that he was not worried about the audience's disgust, because these were all verified, and Cao Cao restored Liu Bei's true face with many historical details.